Achilles vs. Prince Nuada
The Greeks invade the homeland of the Elves, Nuada accidentally kills Achilles' gay-looking cousin, and now Achilles is at the gates of elven kingdom shouting for Nuada to have a one on one with him.
Achilles is armed with his shield and spear, with his sword strapped to his hip.
Nuada is armed with his spear and a spare sword strapped to his hip as well.
For this scenario, we'll assume that Nuada and Achilles are more or less equal in strength, so this just comes down to skill and speed.
Let's also remove the magical properties of Nuada's weapons to make it more fair, just make them normal though highly crafted weapons.
Who wins?