Oh Dae-su vs John Hartigan

Oh Dae-su, from the film Oldboy

VS

John Hartigan, from the film Sin City

This is the post-imprisonment version of both combatants. They are fighting to the death in an abandoned warehouse at midnight. They know nothing of each other prior to the fight. Nobody else will intervene. They start off unarmed but there are various objects, such as hammers, screwdrivers, crowbars, etc, lying around the warehouse for them to use.

Ummm.. does Hartigan's heart condition apply to this?

As I said in the thread, it's the post-imprisonment versions of both combatants.

Then most likely he'd die to heart condition so... kind of a bad match up.

Post-imprisonment versions, dude. Hartigan no longer has a heart condition.

Originally posted by SSJVegeta
Post-imprisonment versions, dude. Hartigan no longer has a heart condition.

He still had it after to, he even said that he thought that they fixed it.

Originally posted by SSJVegeta
Post-imprisonment versions, dude. Hartigan no longer has a heart condition.

He definitely had a heart condition after prison. Watch the movie again bro.

Hartigan's ticker gets the best of him.

They did fix it. He fakes a heart attack at one point, if that's what you mean. Hartigan went through hospital before prison.

At any rate, it's pretty boring to discuss an old man dying of a heart attack, and Hartigan is still a very capable fighter, as is Dae-su, so think about the original fight: assuming both combatants are fine health-wise, who wins in the above situation?