Originally posted by keiththegreat
Odin is more overrated IMO. People saying he went toe-to-toe with Galactus, when he headbutted him and knocked himself out, while Galactus was fine. When was the last time Odin destroyed a galaxy? Why did Odin have to rely on Thor to fight the Serpent? Why does Odin constantly look to Thor to save Asgard? The physical force of headbutting Galactus knocked Odin out. If you don't think WORLDBREAKER HULK getting 15 free attacks on him in a closed arena isn't going to hurt him, you're delusional.
Actually I agree with you here. In a pure slugfest WBH would beat Odin, except if Odin was allowed to amp.
WBH punches would damage him though.
Odin is RIDICULOUSLY overrated on this site. By some people's reckoning he's on par with Galactus. That being said, Odin would definitely feel some pain here, but he'll still win. You could tell Zeus felt the punch that Hulk gave to him, and that was a far weaker Hulk. So Odin will definitely feel this.
Originally posted by keiththegreat
Odin is more overrated IMO. People saying he went toe-to-toe with Galactus, when he headbutted him and knocked himself out, while Galactus was fine. When was the last time Odin destroyed a galaxy? Why did Odin have to rely on Thor to fight the Serpent? Why does Odin constantly look to Thor to save Asgard? The physical force of headbutting Galactus knocked Odin out. If you don't think WORLDBREAKER HULK getting 15 free attacks on him in a closed arena isn't going to hurt him, you're delusional.
So this is a bait thread to attempt to enlighten KMC that Odin is overrated, even more so than the likes of those I mentioned?
Seriously, this is the one thing I hate about KMC. Posters get annoyed about one character being held in high esteem by a poster or several and then claim that character is the most overrated/wanked character on the forum.
I mean, look at the shit people have said about Superman, Hulk, Silver Surfer, Superboy Prime, Wolverine, Batman, etc.
Every single moderately popular character here has fanboys of some kind. The idea that somehow, Odin has the most/fervent is laughable. Do people overrate him? Sure. But let's not say he's the worse when that top slot is tied amongst about three to half a dozen others at any given time.
Originally posted by Harbinger
Doesn't hurt that their one on one confrontation supports this to an extent.
How so? Only one of them was left standing after the fight, and Galactus didn't look any worse for wear after the fight, while Odin couldn't even stand without Thor's help. Despite Odin having all of Asgard along with him.
Originally posted by PillarofOsiris
How so? Only one of them was left standing after the fight, and Galactus didn't look any worse for wear after the fight, while Odin couldn't even stand without Thor's help. Despite Odin having all of Asgard along with him.
Odin physically damaged Galactus (who had to reform afterword) and prior to that was contending with him on the psychic plane.
The comic showed us Galactus > Odin. But it's not to the degree that some people think it should have been, which is the issue.
Originally posted by PillarofOsirisTheir extended psi battle (where neither seemed to have an edge) before Fraction decided to have Odin and Big G fight the most awkward battle ever.
How so? Only one of them was left standing after the fight, and Galactus didn't look any worse for wear after the fight, while Odin couldn't even stand without Thor's help. Despite Odin having all of Asgard along with him.
Always interpreted their face-off as Galactus being Odin's superior, but not so much that Big G could simply win without resistance. IOW, Odin isn't equal to Galactus, but he's powerful enough to make Big G work.
Originally posted by keiththegreat
Is there a purpose to any thread on this site? It's debating two ficitional characters. Dumb question answered.
I think his question had more to do with the fact that this thread is either an overt bait thread and/or obviously has an agenda. If you disagree with this assessment, I'd encourage you to really scrutinize your "Odin is the most wanked..." post, and be truthful with yourself about whether or not your opinion on the characters and debaters on KMC had nothing to do with this
Because, yes, each thread is debating two fictional characters. You are, in an absolutist, somewhat childish manner, correct. The question directed at you, however, was not pertaining to this. So the response of "dumb question answered" is either not picking up the questioner's intent, or willfully ignoring it to try to make him seem dumb. Ignorance or vitriol, essentially. The former of those is excusable, if lamentable. The latter, less so.
In any case, I doubt too many care a whole lot about your opinion on this fight anymore; their personal feelings toward your attitude in the thread have likely invalidated any pure notions of comic debate. You'd be better off approaching your opinions in less passive-aggressive ways. Or, if you truly aren't making this because of an opinion or agenda, your words are not doing a good job of conveying it, and you'd do well to analyze how your actions will affect others' opinions of you and your ability to debate rationally with one another.
Originally posted by Harbinger
Their extended psi battle (where neither seemed to have an edge) before Fraction decided to have Odin and Big G fight the most awkward battle ever.Always interpreted their face-off as Galactus being Odin's superior, but not so much that Big G could simply win without resistance. IOW, Odin isn't equal to Galactus, but he's powerful enough to make Big G work.
👆
Originally posted by JakeTheBankso what...beta ray bill damaged galactus.
Odin physically damaged Galactus (who had to reform afterword) and prior to that was contending with him on the psychic plane.The comic showed us Galactus > Odin. But it's not to the degree that some people think it should have been, which is the issue.
as I have said before, galactus durability is highly overrated on this site, as I have always said juggernaut is more durable than galactus
Re: Worldbreaker Hulk vs Odin
Originally posted by keiththegreat
WBH and Odin are in a closed arena the size of a football field. There is no BFR. WBH thinks Odin just maliciously killed Betty and Skaar.WBH gets [b]TEN free double fisted punches
on Odin, who has no weapons. Then WBH gets FIVE free thunderclaps. After all that Odin can fight back but only head to head (no energy drains, no time freezing, etc). It's a pure slugfest. (though he can amp his physical stats). Who wins?Hulk is going to be hitting Odin as hard as he possibly can with his free hits. [/B]
Odin. Once the free hits are done, Hulk better make peace with what ever god he prays to because he's gonna have his shiet pushed in.
Originally posted by Starscream M
so what...beta ray bill damaged galactus.as I have said before, galactus durability is highly overrated on this site, as I have always said juggernaut is more durable than galactus
Beta Ray Bill didn't force Galactus to expend energy to repair himself as soon as he was damaged, either and didn't force his way into Galactus' mind, either.
Yeah, you say a bunch of stuff, most of them wrong.
The psi battle wasn't going to put Galactus down. Not by a long shot. And by the logic we're using here, Thor can contend with Galactus too, since Galactus had to reform his helmet after Thor flew through it. Fact is Galactus wasn't even hurt and he was fighting like a moron. He was perfectly fine while Odin couldn't stand after the fight and would have been killed if Galactus kept pressing the issue. And Odin had his entire army at his back.
Not to mention, if we're going by feats, Odin isn't even in the same ballpark as Galactus. Fights are one thing. Even if Odin had beaten Galactus, it would have been a case of Spiderman/Firelord.
I don't want to get too off topic though, so that's the last I'll say about Odin/Galactus.