Ymir vs Silverage Mangog vs Surtur

Started by zopzop2 pages
zopzop Lord of the Great Abyss

Originally posted by Horrificus
Don't get me wrong zop, Ymir knows his air conditioners!

But, Mangog was MUCH more powerful than Odin. We probably will never know how Mangog would do against the CoAW, and maybe it would do him in. But strength for strength, power for power, Silver Age Mangog should be able to deal with either of these guys. It's just the way he was written.


I'd agree with you if the OP said : Ymir vs Mangog vs Surtur on a neutral battlefield. But that's not what was stated. It's Surtur with Twilight vs Ymir with the CoAW vs Mangog. Also look where the fight takes place. This is Ymir's fight to lose.
Originally posted by guy222
cool

have a good evening


I'm kidding guy, I'm not really angry 😛

Horrificus Senior Member

Originally posted by zopzop
I'd agree with you if the OP said : Ymir vs Mangog vs Surtur on a neutral battlefield. But that's not what was stated. It's Surtur with Twilight vs Ymir with the CoAW vs Mangog. Also look where the fight takes place. This is Ymir's fight to lose.

I'm kidding guy, I'm not really angry 😛

Yeah, yer right.

But, then between Ymir and Surtur, what would be the outcome?

zopzop Lord of the Great Abyss

Originally posted by Horrificus
Yeah, yer right.

But, then between Ymir and Surtur, what would be the outcome?


They "fought" before on neutral ground and it was basically a tie. Surtur had Twilight and Ymir had a generic ice club. Their weapons clashed and they were both BFRed. This happened in an 80s Defender's issue. Dr. Strange basically tped them in front of each other as each was swinging their weapons. This caused a backlash and they were both BFRed from Earth (neutral ground to them both).

I think they "fought" on two other occasions and the outcome was basically the same or something. Maybe Rage or Dam can help me out here.

I give it to Ymir because of the location the fight is taking place in (land of eternal ice and darkness), his personal power, and the Casket.

guy222 With my gal

Originally posted by zopzop
I'd agree with you if the OP said : Ymir vs Mangog vs Surtur on a neutral battlefield. But that's not what was stated. It's Surtur with Twilight vs Ymir with the CoAW vs Mangog. Also look where the fight takes place. This is Ymir's fight to lose.

I'm kidding guy, I'm not really angry 😛

i know good friend

how's ur sunday

wish the casket would return

zopzop Lord of the Great Abyss

Originally posted by guy222
i know good friend

how's ur sunday

wish the casket would return


Good so far 🙂

PS does anyone have scans confirming that Ymir created and/or empowers the Casket? I heard a forum member say something to that effect here.

Rage, Dam, or any other Thor fan know?

pym-ftw Mizukage

I'm trying to find the scan where it is referenced as "The FimbulWinter of Ymir"