The Punisher vs The Comedian

1.H2H
2.Both can use standard weopens , overall whose better at using firearms and a better assasinator?

Who wins in each of the above

If Punisher started this fight with two broken knee caps, he'd still solo every character from the Watchman sans Dr Manhattan. 10/10.

kinda surprised you're not giving Frank a win or two versus Manhattan. 313

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
If Punisher started this fight with two broken knee caps, he'd still solo every character from the Watchman sans Dr Manhattan. 10/10.

Originally posted by marwash22
kinda surprised you're not giving Frank a win or two versus Manhattan. 313

A bit closer than the previous Punisher vs. Rorschach match, but Frank still beats this Watchmen anti-hero handily. Only Ozymandias (and obviously Dr. M) from Watchmen would reliably beat Punisher.

Comedian at his best could give Frank a fight.. but it still wouldn`t be close.

Originally posted by Mshinu
Comedian at his best could give Frank a fight.. but it still wouldn`t be close.

Castle would beat the crap out of the Comedian.

Originally posted by Eternal Idol
How would he give him a fight if it wouldn't even be close?

You can give someone a fight and still loose 9/10 or 10/10.
Comedian is not a pushover, but he is a notch and a half below Punisher and has no advantages.

Young Comedian or old Comedian. But honestly I see the two of these guys giving eachother the nod and saying carry on.

Originally posted by marwash22
kinda surprised you're not giving Frank a win or two versus Manhattan. 313

You've convinced me, Punisher also beats Dr Manhattan.

Originally posted by Uriel005
Young Comedian or old Comedian. But honestly I see the two of these guys giving eachother the nod and saying carry on.

Comedian is a rapist, Punisher would kill.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
You've convinced me, Punisher also beats Dr Manhattan.

Comedian is a rapist, Punisher would kill.

Space Punisher ever worse so

I'd give Frank the nod over Ozy

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
You've convinced me, Punisher also beats Dr Manhattan.

Comedian is a rapist, Punisher would kill.

Comedian prob will be an ass and boast about what a ladies man he is.

Punisher is what Comedian wants to be when he grows up.

Space Punisher is the god he prays to before he goes to bed at night and the one he thanks for letting him wake up.