Originally posted by marwash22
MoS is at 56%, and at one it was even lower than that.Rotten Tomatoes is a joke.
RT gets it mostly right; doesn't mean I agree with it all the time. MOS's score has it in the mixed reviews range - I generally consider anything that scores from the high 40's to the low 70's to have gotten a mixed critical response. If audience favour was all that mattered, then the People's Choice Awards would be just as important as the Oscars.
Right now, TLR is in Green Lantern/Fantastic Four misfire territory. I'll be surprised if moves up into mixed reception territory.
Originally posted by Patient_Leech
Do you mean to say that you weren't impressed with the performance or character?
I wasn't impressed with his acting. It's the same as his Jack Sparrow persona. Only more reserved. PRetty much the whole movie had the Pirates of the Caribbean vibe. Wasn't bad, just seemed like I've seen it all before.
Except the action sequence on the train was fun. I will give it that much
Originally posted by roughrider
RT gets it mostly right; doesn't mean I agree with it all the time. MOS's score has it in the mixed reviews range - I generally consider anything that scores from the high 40's to the low 70's...Right now, TLR is in Green Lantern/Fantastic Four misfire territory. I'll be surprised if moves up into mixed reception territory.
Yeah, the 70s scores can be very misleading. Captain America and Fast 6 are both in the 70s and I thought they deserved a 30 - 50% at best. And it's funny you mention Green Lantern because that's clearly a bomb according to RT, but I actually enjoy it, even though there's plenty of reasons not to. And Pitch Black (55%) and the CoR (29%). Yeah, I clearly don't agree with those. I'd give Pitch Black 5/5 stars and the CoR 4.5/5 stars, heh. So, I guess movies are just very personal that way. I have to take RT with a grain of salt. It's very useful, though.
(Public Enemies (68%) is another movie that I felt was rated WAY too high)
Originally posted by Filmigos
I wasn't impressed with his acting. It's the same as his Jack Sparrow persona. Only more reserved. PRetty much the whole movie had the Pirates of the Caribbean vibe. Wasn't bad, just seemed like I've seen it all before.
Didn't mind this movie
the only thing i didn't really like about it were those flashbacks to San Francisco with that kid
also the humor in this is like the kinda stuff you would get with the POTC movies
8/10
i've only read one review
-comparing Depp's Tonto to Jack Sparrow
-the reviewer didn't like how long the movie went for
-also felt the movie was boring.