Originally posted by mnat801
Seeing that anakin couldnt break obi wans defence 3 years later, I dont think theres any reason to believe he could be successful here.
Obi wan wins with moderate difficulty.
You're thinking of Vader.
Anakin broke Dooku's defense, and I'm sure it's better than Obi-wan's by a little bit, so he could break Obi-wan's as well.
Vader, couldn't though.
Regardless, Anakin wins here - his master got dropped in under 10 seconds by Dooku - whereas Anakin gave Dooku a good fight and held him off for a good deal longer.
I'd think the math would be simple.
Originally posted by BattlemasterAnakin/Vader same person.
You're thinking of Vader.Anakin broke Dooku's defense, and I'm sure it's better than Obi-wan's by a little bit, so he could break Obi-wan's as well.
Vader, couldn't though.
Regardless, Anakin wins here - his master got dropped in under 10 seconds by Dooku - whereas Anakin gave Dooku a good fight and held him off for a good deal longer.
I'd think the math would be simple.
Even though anakin lasted longer against dooku, obi wan still was anakins master and taught him everything he knew, so that would give him the advantage. Imo.
Originally posted by mnat801
Anakin/Vader same person.
Anakin/Vader same person - different Persona's.
They aren't the same person mentally, and that's where it counts.
The fight is under the hat - not the glove.
Originally posted by mnat801
Even though anakin lasted longer against dooku, obi wan still was anakins master and taught him everything he knew, so that would give him the advantage. Imo.
Yeah, Obi-wan knew Anakin's moves - and Anakin knew Obi-wan's moves.
Either they both have an advantage, or neither of them do.
It's a two-way street; a double-edged sword.