Superman vs Sinestro: 3 Rounds

Originally posted by abhilegend
His durability wasn't amped like all BLs. He wasn't even scratched by that combined assault let alone the possibility of dying and sinestro was shown "killing" BLs left and right.

But he couldn't die from that attack to begin with, not without a Green Lantern to contribute. I don't see how that's something that applies to regular Superman. At all, really.

And if you do something think that feat is valid for regular non-Black Ring wearing Superman, it's certainly so far beyond his typical displays it may as well be rendered an incredibly high end feat. We saw Hank w/ rings manage to lay into Superman. I certainly don't think Hank w/ 10 Qwardian rings >= Sinestro, Atrocitus, and Larfleeze all attacking at once with the intent to kill. And we also know that any of the elite Lanterns on their own is capable of harming Superman conventionally, as well.

So, yeah. Not seeing how that example can even begin to be applied for regular Superman.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
But he couldn't die from that attack to begin with, not without a Green Lantern to contribute. I don't see how that's something that applies to regular Superman. At all, really.

And if you do something think that feat is valid for regular non-Black Ring wearing Superman, it's certainly so far beyond his typical displays it may as well be rendered an incredibly high end feat. We saw Hank w/ rings manage to lay into Superman. I certainly don't think Hank w/ 10 Qwardian rings >= Sinestro, Atrocitus, and Larfleeze all attacking at once with the intent to kill. And we also know that any of the elite Lanterns on their own is capable of harming Superman conventionally, as well.

So, yeah. Not seeing how that example can even begin to be applied for regular Superman.

That was a holding back superman. Later he nearly killed the same henshaw. Which lanterns are we talking about? Hal came with everything he had and superman tanked that while not fighting back. John had to attack his eyes after he shrugged off a blast that koed the league. An ion amped kyle's Id (heh, his Ids are more powerful than him. Hello oblivion!) managed to scratch him in the face when superman walked through his all out blast. Byrne superman pushed through a mindcontrolled kilowog's all out blast and later he stunned superman with two rings via a suckershot and after that superman was beating him while fighting mind-controll. This is superman, feats like these aren't outside his range.

As nice a feat as it is, the BL "amp" is too ambiguous to use it as some sort of bar for Superman's durability.

As much as I'd like to, it can't be used, I don't think.

Originally posted by -Pr-
As nice a feat as it is, the BL "amp" is too ambiguous to use it as some sort of bar for Superman's durability.

As much as I'd like to, it can't be used, I don't think.

Originally posted by abhilegend
There was no amp. BL Kal-L was getting his face messed up by superman's blows and superboy shattered his whole body apart by his TTK. Black ring seemed to downgrade durability actually seeing how even PG was able to tear flesh out of Kal-L's face with a blow.

I don't agree.

Nevertheless, a change is still a change, and can't be applied to the standard version of a character.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I don't agree.

Nevertheless, a change is still a change, and can't be applied to the standard version of a character.

If a character gets a power up which doesn't increases any of his powers but gives him other powers instead and he uses his standard powers, it can be used for his standard self AFAIK. There is no logical reason it shouldn't.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Ok. Doesn't mean that I'm wrong.

If a character gets a power up which doesn't increases any of his powers but gives him other powers instead and he uses his standard powers, it can be used for his standard self AFAIK. There is no logical reason it shouldn't.

Never said it did make you wrong, just that it wasn't usable.

We saw that people infected with black rings had their bodies affected. Whether you don't think it's an amp or not, fair enough, but it doesn't make it usable.

There was a time when I thought it was, but reading back, it's just not representative considering the alterations black rings cause.

It's not valid. Sorry.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Never said it did make you wrong, just that it wasn't usable.

We saw that people infected with black rings had their bodies affected. Whether you don't think it's an amp or not, fair enough, but it doesn't make it usable.

There was a time when I thought it was, but reading back, it's just not representative considering the alterations black rings cause.

It's not valid. Sorry.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So despite the facts to the contrary, its not valid. Sigh, Ok. FTR Black rings only gave a HF, there isn't a single proof it increased durability. Its like superman getting increased durability and claiming that his strength feats are invalid due to it. But seeing this is a Mod ruling, I concede.

"Facts" as you see them.

I read Blackest Night too, you know. I'm not just picking an opinion out of the air and running with it. Alterations are alterations, so no, it's not really the same thing.

Okay then.

Originally posted by -Pr-
"Facts" as you see them.

I read Blackest Night too, you know. I'm not just picking an opinion out of the air and running with it. Alterations are alterations, so no, it's not really the same thing.

Okay then.

Ok.

Originally posted by -Pr-
"Facts" as you see them.

I read Blackest Night too, you know. I'm not just picking an opinion out of the air and running with it. Alterations are alterations, so no, it's not really the same thing.

Okay then.

😂

Originally posted by abhilegend
Facts as comics stated. Never said you didn't. It didn't give him an amp in durability which is the ability used here, its all his own durability.

Ok.

You done now? Good.

Originally posted by Mindset
Pr, keep picking on abhi and I'm gonna get Phil on you again!

Originally posted by -Pr-
You done now? Good.

Superman beats the shit out of sinestro anyway.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Tyrant mods.uhuh

Superman beats the shit out of sinestro anyway.

You have no idea.

Well yeah, that's obvious. It is Superman after all.

Originally posted by -Pr-
You have no idea.

Well yeah, that's obvious. It is Superman after all.

Damn right!

Originally posted by abhilegend
I vote delph in the next mod elections.sneer

Damn right!

Originally posted by abhilegend
I vote delph in the next mod elections.sneer

Damn right!

Yeah, cos that worked so well last time.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Yeah, cos that worked so well last time.

Abhi, will you protect him this time?

Will you be his Superman?