Halloween archtypes : Marvel Vs DC

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I think he is passing on second hand info from prep-man... I'm sure prep-man said the fallowing about Timber Wolf. But we all know prep-man is insane.

lol

Originally posted by abhilegend
A little harsh, don't you think? Prep-man is a little biased towards DC, but he ain't insane.

I like prep-man, but he is almost certainly insane. Just look at the squash matches he routinely makes thinking they are even fights...

Plus there is his current set:

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I like prep-man, but he is almost certainly insane. Just look at the squash matches he routinely makes thinking they are even fights...

Plus there is his current set:

@ srankmissingnin
He did go up against Sun Emperor and win (withstanding some brutal energy attacks too). Plus it wasn't just Prep-Man, other forum members spoke highly of Timber Wolf. But I guess it doesn't matter for the purposes of this thread since he's not a Lycanthrope anyway.

Ok, to recap, we have DC winning in every single category with the exception of Werewolf and Scarecrow.

Can anyone comment on the Frankenstein's Monster category? That's the only undecided left.

^What has marvel's frankenstein done? DC's frankenstein has taken on people like flash, bizarro and wonder woman and at least held his own. Not to mention the sword of michael is hax.

Originally posted by zopzop
@ srankmissingnin
He did go up against Sun Emperor and win (withstanding some brutal energy attacks too). Plus it wasn't just Prep-Man, other forum members spoke highly of Timber Wolf. But I guess it doesn't matter for the purposes of this thread since he's not a Lycanthrope anyway.

Ok, to recap, we have DC winning in every single category with the exception of Werewolf and Scarecrow.

Can anyone comment on the Frankenstein's Monster category? That's the only undecided left.

That was 3boot Timberwolf, not DCnU, and classifying 3boot Sun Emperor a Herald is a stretch.

Marvel should win the Mummy category handily. I can't really think of a Mummy character in DC of any merit... I think there was one in a few issues of Countdown, but I don't think he was as powerful as the Living Mummy.

Frankencastle with the bloodstone, would probably edge out Frankenstein, unless Frankie knew enough to remove the gem.

Dracula at his best defeated Silver Surfer, but average portray would probably lose to Bennett.

There is also Mummy Thor, Vampire Wolverine, Werewolf Cap, and the return of Frankencastle coming up in Secret Avengers, with Demon DD and some spidermonster Spider-man.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
That was 3boot Timberwolf, not DCnU, and classifying 3boot Sun Emperor a Herald is a stretch.

Marvel should win the Mummy category handily. I can't really think of a Mummy character in DC of any merit... I think there was one in a few issues of Countdown, but I don't think he was as powerful as the Living Mummy.

Frankencastle with the bloodstone, would probably edge out Frankenstein, unless Frankie knew enough to remove the gem.

Dracula at his best defeated Silver Surfer, but average portray would probably lose to Bennett.

There is also Mummy Thor, Vampire Wolverine, Werewolf Cap, and the return of Frankencastle coming up in Secret Avengers, with Demon DD and some spidermonster Spider-man.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Dracula didn't beat surfer IIRC. Which fight are you talking about? Tomb of dracula 50?

Surfer was laid out and Dracula left... I guess you could call it a stalemate, but Dracula clearly had the advantage.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Surfer was laid out and Dracula left... I guess you could call it a stalemate, but Dracula clearly had the advantage.

That was after the fight concluded. Dracula beat Surfer and left. Surfer composed himself and went after Dracula again. Surfer said there is no point in fighting... and then he left.

Though if we're talking about converted heroes, PC superman solos. He's been converted in every category listed here at least once.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
That was after the fight concluded. Dracula beat Surfer and left. Surfer composed himself and went after Dracula again. Surfer said there is no point in fighting... and then he left.

Ghost for Marvel could be Daniel Drumm

It was actually Q that said Timber Wolf was Namor level. Not me.

^Q99? Really?

Creeper would be cool at a Halloween party.

Originally posted by abhilegend
^Q99? Really?

Yes.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-561571-timber-wolf-vs-sabretooth.html

Originally posted by Existere
Well, for zombies, Marvel had, you know.... Marvel Zombies. mmm

And for Scarecrow, DC has, you know.... Scarecrow. 😐

So final score :
DC -
Vampires - Carnivore, Cain (honorable mention)
Ghosts - Spectre
Zombies - Genocide
Frankenstein's Monster - Frankenstein with Sword of Michael

Marvel -
Werewolves (since DC doesn't seem to have any worth mentioning) - Werewolf by Night
Mummies - (since DC doesn't have any worth mentioning) - The Living Mummy with Eye of Ra
Scarecrows - Strawman

The mummy and werewolf categories had some pretty sad contestants 🙁