Would you be surprised? · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

carver9 Senior Member

Would you be surprised?

If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.

If Captain America held his own against Superman.

If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.

If Thor took out Galactus again.

If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.

If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).

If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.

You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

JakeTheBank Return of the King

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

The only one that I can't ever see happening is the last one. While the others would likely set off fanboy alarms, that last one would probably make people want to kill others and themselves.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

No.

Yes.

No.

Yes.

Anything can happen in comics but Captain Marvel becoming the number one hero over Superman is the biggest stretch.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.

He already embarrassed him pretty bad in a story drawn by Keith.

Originally posted by carver9
If Captain America held his own against Superman.

I'd be surprised if Supes managed to hold his own 😂

Originally posted by carver9
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.

It's only a matter of time.

Originally posted by carver9
If Thor took out Galactus again.

When did he take him out?

Originally posted by carver9
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.

No.

Originally posted by carver9
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).

Yes.

Originally posted by carver9
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.

Yes.

Badabing Gym rat

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

Batman has already defeated Lobo in a moni.

Branlor Swift Dead

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9

If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

Ignoring the Batman one, because it's happened.

No

Yes

No

He already is.

Digi Forum Leader

Yeah, when did Thor defeat Galactus?

Cogito Senior Member

Re: Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
No.
Yes.
Yes.
No.
No.
Yes.
Yes.
Anything can happen in comics but Captain Marvel becoming the number one hero over Superman is the biggest stretch.

Cosigned. Though Darkseid at PC levels isn't that big of a stretch, I would be surprised.

Batman-Prime Kryptonian Scientist

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

No. Is good enough skillwise to do so. See also Hitman vs Lobo.

No. He would start a moral speech.

No. Zeus and Odin unamped are below Hulk, physically.

Aain? You answered this.

No, superman defeated stronger enemies, like Darkseid.

No.

Yes.

comicfan11 Ocean's Heaviest Hitter

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

It's about being pissed and not surprised. I don't believe anything can surprise me in comics anymore.

I'd be pissed with 1,2,3,7

I'd have no problem with 4,5,6 (4 only via godblast, 5 via speed)

TheGodKiller True Killer

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

No.

Yes.

No.

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

Re: Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Zeus and Odin unamped are below Hulk, physically.

Based on what information are you coming to this conclusion? I've read so much Thor related material and yet I'm still unable to understand how people are able to define and separate "unamped" Odin from his appearances.

Sin I AM Madame Mort

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Based on what information are you coming to this conclusion? I've read so much Thor related material and yet I'm still unable to understand how people are able to define and separate "unamped" Odin from his appearances.

They have no basis, the amped umamped argument derives failed "official" bios

Mshinu Star for a Brain

I would only be suprised if Bugboy Parker was rectonned to not lose his anal virginity. Everything else is believable, it is comics after all.

Batman-Prime Kryptonian Scientist

Re: Re: Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Based on what information are you coming to this conclusion? I've read so much Thor related material and yet I'm still unable to understand how people are able to define and separate "unamped" Odin from his appearances.

Hulks feats, common sense, the fight against Zeus and last but not least Marvel U Hanbooks.

Mindship Snap out of it.

I'd be surprised if Surfer started to remember to hover when knocked off-board. I'd also be surprised if Diana discovered tanking blows from Superman meant she really doesn't need to block bullets.

-Pr- Hey Yo!

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
No.
Yes.
Yes.
No.
No.
Yes.
Yes.
Anything can happen in comics but Captain Marvel becoming the number one hero over Superman is the biggest stretch.

that'll do.

Damborgson King of the Damboys

Originally posted by Digi
Yeah, when did Thor defeat Galactus?

ares834 Senior Member

No.
Yes.
Yes.
Yes.
No.
Yes.
Yes.

Damborgson King of the Damboys

Re: Would you be surprised?

Originally posted by carver9
If Batman defeated Lobo in a fist fight.
If Captain America held his own against Superman.
If Hulk got revenge and defeated Zeus.
If Thor took out Galactus again.
If Superman defeated Thanos in a crossover.
If Darkseid was written back to his classic ways (precrisis).
If Captain Marvel became the main DC hero.
You can add to this off you want to add something that would be surprising.

no

yes

no

yes