Anakin vs. Luke

In an alternate Star Wars Universe where Anakin never turned to the dark side and both father and son have achieved their highest possible potential in the light side of the Force. They are in an open area in the Jedi Temple. In three rounds (sabers, force, and all-out), who is the winner: father, or son?

Anakin.

/thread

Kyle Katarn stomps both of them.

Lonny Lion and Tyler Tiger would stomp them too.

The Boss soloes.

Okay, I let it go for four posts... Please stay on topic, and don't bring any unrelated characters into this discussion. Thanks.

Really can't say, I guess Anakin because he's "teh FORCE" and shit. Kinda a dumb description to be honest.

Originally posted by jmoul
Okay, I let it go for four posts... Please stay on topic, and don't bring any unrelated characters into this discussion. Thanks.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Lawl at you thinking you're boss.

Sorry. I should have said "Lawl at you thinking your demands mean anything."

Anakin because he was trained more

Originally posted by jmoul
In an alternate Star Wars Universe where Anakin never turned to the dark side and both father and son have achieved their highest possible potential in the light side of the Force. They are in an open area in the Jedi Temple. In three rounds (sabers, force, and all-out), who is the winner: father, or son?

Not only is Anakin greater than his son, he's also greater than DE Sidious, Father, Son, Daughter, and Abeloth. He's the most powerful Force wielder yet. But he'd be stronger as a Sith...

Luke was far more naturally talented and prodigious with the Force than his father, if you factor that in, he will be more skilled and reach his potential a lot quicker.

Actually he did reach his potential, the outcome was him being even more skilled in the Force than Revan, and comparable in power to Yoda. With an arsenal like Revan from his creativity and instant learning only observed by the Sith who are in commune with the Dark Side.

He even achieved Oneness with the Living Force (as oppossed to the Dark Side using the doctrine of Potentium (how the light side can be stronger than the dark side)) without dying or turning into a Force Ghost, although he did eventually become a Force Ghost.

Any Gray Jedi who achieves Oneness with the Living Force (Light Side) using the Doctrine of Potentium has reached a potential greater than they could as Sith using their Doctrine of the Dark, without their bodies being corrupted to boot.

Potentium/Oneness>The Dark/Oneness

The Sith>The Jedi

Although Oneness with the Light Side isn't by choice.

Really anything I say about Oneness, the Dark, and Potentium is opinionated, and off-topic, sorry.

But Anakin had a greater potential.

Luke because Anakin has got ****ed up mentality. Some things can't be cured even with experience.

Yeah, Luke being the one who isn't a psychopath should make it easier for him to be... light sidey.

I thought Luke achieved the potential of his father?

Anyway, I'd probably say Anakin just because he is GL's "Chosen One."

Don't forget, this is an alternate No-Darth-Vader universe. Anakin never gets mentally f***ed up in this universe

So he's... not Anakin, he's someone completely different.

We can't really argue this thread. All in all, it would probably be some epic fight that is more or less a standstill with Anakin probably being the one who wins.

Plo Koon solos.

/Thread

Not that he isn't Anakin, it is him, but he has realized his light-side potential by not turning to the dark side. Since Luke is Anakin's Force-potential realized, we know how Powerful Anakin would have been in the light side. Given that and Anakin's saber skills, I am asking which Skywalker was most powerful.