Tobey Maguire vs Andrew Garfield

If that's true, then general opinion can kiss my ass 🙂

I didn't think it was terrible. I thought it was midicore. But like another poster said I liked it much better then Dunst and Maguire. That could be my personal bias against Kirstin Dunst though.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
If that's true, then general opinion can kiss my ass 🙂

Originally posted by Arachnid1
And minority opinion can kiss my ass. wavey

I'll eat your soul.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
No Tobey's acting was terrible.

* he wasn't that good... but he wasn't that bad either...

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Parker/Spiderman is a wisecracking cocky SOB. Tobey could hardly talk properly let alone pull that off.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Garfield on the other hand pulled it off brilliantly.

* nah... exchange their scripts, and you'll reverse your argument... if Tobey was given Garfield's role, he could've pull it off as well...

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Well no because they could have easily made it a Spidey 4, and begged Maguire to stay if he was that good. But the fact is, he was very replaceable.

* so is Garfield... i think the difference here is not the actor but the script given... if Tobey was given a better script and a better story, he could've pull it off as well...

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Oh please. That was such a well done romance story. In comparison the Maguire/Dunst romance was just not believable at all!

* i do agree that Garfield-Stone loveteam has a chemistry more than Maguire-Dunst... but Maguire-Dunst, inspite the lack of chemsitry, managed to create an iconic kissing scene (with Spidey updown) that makes up for it... with that alone, Garfield-Stone pales in comparison...

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
^ It seems like your dislike of the new film is making you bias.

Garfield was sooooo much better as Parker. Tobey's just not a good actor. The guy can hardly speak. That's why he's had no success since Spiderman 3 which was 5 years ago now.

Garfield on the other hand clearly has a great career ahead of him.

you nailed it,could not have said it better myself. 🤘 👆

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
No Tobey's acting was terrible. Parker/Spiderman is a wisecracking cocky SOB. Tobey could hardly talk properly let alone pull that off.

Garfield on the other hand pulled it off brilliantly.

Well no because they could have easily made it a Spidey 4, and begged Maguire to stay if he was that good. But the fact is, he was very replaceable.

Oh please. That was such a well done romance story. In comparison the Maguire/Dunst romance was just not believable at all!

you took the maguire apologists to school there. 💃

Toby Maguire all the way.