Gordon, the point I was making is that it is not acceptable to criticise someone for BEING critical. Enyafreak was not criticising my point of view, simply that I had taken a critical viewpoint and that is not right.
And I have no idea why you think my criticism was aggressive, enyafreak. But what certainly was aggressive, unjustifed and, basically, untrue (as myself and Julie HAD presented opinions) is what you said and it will be appreciated if you do not make such comments in future.
I do not grill people for creativity- considering I run the RP section that would be an odd thing to do seeing as it is nothing BUT creativity. I dislike wild speculation. That is all. But that I dislike such speculation made no difference to the arguments I raised against it which would have been the same, wild idea or otherwise.
Now, Evil Windu presented his theory for analysis. Some of us have said our piece. If you do not like what we said then make a counter-argument but do NOT criticise us for saying what we did because we have every right to do so.
I hope this is clear to everyone. Now again threads are being bogged down in utterly unncessary complication so PLEASE keep things on track and keep this purely about opinion and discussion of the idea presented. You will note that whatever I say about this theory as presented by Windu (and his friend) I have absolutely no criticism at all of HIM. Furhter negative comments made about people simply for being critical will be trated as member bashing and dealt with accordingly.
So, either more comments or ideas about the theory or nothing at all from now on, thanks.
I hate it when Ush has to tell us all off, he's younger than me and yet I still feel like I'm in front of the head master, let's all just play nicely so he doesn't scare me again.
And yes, although EW's idea was creative, it fail in the points that Ush raised, it struck me immediately that Palpatine would not have had the time to be 3 different people and I do think that syfo dias has to be another person.