Who is the most eternal?

Meaning they can't die or be killed?

My vote is Dr. Manhattan and possibly Sentry.

The Phoenix Force

Originally posted by armedforbattle
The Phoenix Force

Power Equal to or greater than Manhatten?

Originally posted by Supra
Power Equal to or greater than Manhatten?

Batman and Hulk. sneer

Seriously, DCnU Captain Atom.

Originally posted by armedforbattle
If you are asking if the phoenix Force is stronger then Dr Manhattan?
Then yes, wayyyy more powerful

But neither can die or be killed. Interesting. Manhattan would be the type that just teleports away if he's not interested in it or just phase out to a different dimension.

Originally posted by Badabing
Batman and Hulk. sneer

Seriously, DCnU Captain Atom.

Haha Oh shit I forgot about batman!

How come captain atom cannot be killed..I'm guessing similar makeup as Manhattan ?

Originally posted by Supra
Haha Oh shit I forgot about batman!

How come captain atom cannot be killed..I'm guessing similar makeup as Manhattan ?

Isnt captain Atom based off Dr Manhattan

Originally posted by Badabing
In the DCnU, he hasn't shown any limits to his power, has control of matter, space and time and was stated to be pure enrgy. He appeared to be Dr. Manhattan on steroids.

Very cool. I'm guessing him and Manhattan would get along well. With Manhattans apathy it's hard to consider him a power player even though he does have incredible power. But not caring makes him weaker even though it is still impossible to kill him.

So you would rank them like this?
1. Phoenix
2. Captain Atom
3. Dr. Manhattan

Originally posted by Supra
Very cool. I'm guessing him and Manhattan would get along well. With Manhattans apathy it's hard to consider him a power player even though he does have incredible power. But not caring makes him weaker even though it is still impossible to kill him.

So you would rank them like this?
1. Phoenix
2. Captain Atom
3. Dr. Manhattan

Franklin Richards(stated to witness the death of this universe and usher in the birth of the next one)

Mr. Immortal(also said to watch the universe die and be the last person alive)

Originally posted by KingD19
Franklin Richards(stated to witness the death of this universe and usher in the birth of the next one)

Mr. Immortal(also said to watch the universe die and be the last person alive)

I think immortal and eternal are different. Like if Dr. Manhattan used his disentegration on Mr. Immortal or Richards would they die and be phased out of existence?

Originally posted by Supra
I think immortal and eternal are different. Like if Dr. Manhattan used his disentegration on Mr. Immortal or Richards would they die and be phased out of existence?

Immortal is beyond death

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Immortal is beyond death

Ok so if disentegration is used on him. He re materializes or it does not work on him?

Originally posted by Supra
Power Equal to or greater than Manhatten?

Lmfao. are you for real?

It's easy to have a lot of implied power in a world where you're the only real super powered being. The SS, Sersi, etc would all appear as powerful as DM in the Watchmen universe. The only difference is the SS would be able to stop ALL OF the USSR's nukes, and not just 60% of them.

Dr. Manhattan isn't even worth discussing in this thread.

By feats he is a poor-man's Silver Surfer.

Immortal can be wounded, so he would prolly be obliterated, but would proceed to be fine in a few moments.

As for Franklin Richards, he is so far above Dr. Manhattan that the notion that he could so much as make his nose run is laughable.

Originally posted by armedforbattle
Isnt captain Atom based off Dr Manhattan

Wrong. Dr. Manhattan is based off of Captain Atom.

Oblivion.

Originally posted by Supra
Ok so if disentegration is used on him. He re materializes or it does not work on him?

Yea exactly he does but he simply just comes back, albeit in a feral state. I could probably just drop him in a sun and he'd keep materializing for years