Point is he did give up. He just stood there, and took Surfers blast, when previously shielded a floating city from 200 plus nukes.
And its clear the following factors took place at the time of Surfers encounter.
>Cable was at the point of burning out, for becoming a global humanitarian without rest.
>A chuck of his TK was being restricted, due to him keeping Providence afloat.
>A chunk of his TP was being restricted, for ionizing the globe with his telepathy.
All things said, I would still give Surfer the win. But a reencounter with a fresh Cable would be more competitive. It would not just end, with hit me eye lasers.