Red Lantern Superman vs Hulk

But no superspeed, and he has to fight without his intelligence, like a roaring rage monster. Any strength gains is negated by Hulk's amping, so:

Strength = equal
Speed = equal
Tactics/intelligence = Hulk, unless Red Supes is like Atrocitus - unlikely though, as most RLs we've seen lose their intelligence.
Healing Factor = Hulk (I haven't seen an Lantern HFs on par with what WWH did when fighting Zom-Strange)
Durability = Superman
Abilities = Superman IF he is like Rankorr and can create constructs, or like Atrocitus. Otherwise, slight edge to Superman with his plasma vom.

In my opinion, the durability and slight edge Superman has in projection does not outweigh Hulk's fighting intelligence. It will be a brutal stalemate until he rips his hand off.

I think Superman will eventually manage to control the rage.

However I don't know if he can do it in time to take the win.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But no superspeed, and he has to fight without his intelligence, like a roaring rage monster. Any strength gains is negated by Hulk's amping, so:

Strength = equal
Speed = equal
Tactics/intelligence = Hulk, unless Red Supes is like Atrocitus - unlikely though, as most RLs we've seen lose their intelligence.
Healing Factor = Hulk (I haven't seen an Lantern HFs on par with what WWH did when fighting Zom-Strange)
Durability = Superman
Abilities = Superman IF he is like Rankorr and can create constructs, or like Atrocitus. Otherwise, slight edge to Superman with his plasma vom.

In my opinion, the durability and slight edge Superman has in projection does not outweigh Hulk's fighting intelligence. It will be a brutal stalemate until he rips his hand off.

Originally posted by Estacado
Meh Rankorr retained most of his intelligence....and he is just a norm human...

Yet Guy, John, Hal etc weren't able to...

Although saying that, Superman is pretty good at controlling his rage.

Even if he could, though, I doubt its going to be a deciding factor.

I thought Rankorr was a special case.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I thought Rankorr was a special case.

Because he was the first human Red Lantern specifically chosen? Or something like that?

Could be. Now I'm sure something like that will be explained. Given how humans are pretty much godlike in all fiction.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Maybe I missed something, but why? Don't recall anything making him that special...well besides him using constructs and such.

the constructs were part of it, and him retaining his intelligence, which red lanterns aren't supposed to do iirc.

Originally posted by googol
H2H only

Strength = equal
Speed = equal
Tactics/intelligence = Hulk, unless Red Supes is like Atrocitus - unlikely though, as most RLs we've seen lose their intelligence.
Healing Factor = Hulk (I haven't seen an Lantern HFs on par with what WWH did when fighting Zom-Strange)
Durability = Superman
Abilities = Equal

So Hulk wins, even more so now in my head.

Originally posted by SevenShackles
What benefits does red lantern superman get? Napalm breath and perminate blood lust correct?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
This. You've taken away Superman's biggest advantages - his speed, his BFR, and his battle smarts.

The RLs never seemed that tactically aware - even when he was bloodlusted (like against Diana in Sacrifice), he still had the tactical nous to carry 'Doomsday' to the Sun, then slam 'him' back to Earth.

Whereas RLs just punch and roar and vomit over everything. Not that it won't work, normally, but remember what happened when a berserk Surfer surprised Hulk with his ferocity? Hulk was stunned, regrouped, then smashed him.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
The RLs never seemed that tactically aware - even when he was bloodlusted (like against Diana in Sacrifice), he still had the tactical nous to carry 'Doomsday' to the Sun, then slam 'him' back to Earth.

Whereas RLs just punch and roar and vomit over everything. Not that it won't work, normally, but remember what happened when a berserk Surfer surprised Hulk with his ferocity? Hulk was stunned, regrouped, then smashed him.

Originally posted by googol
a Blood lusted Superman will rip hulks head off

Without superspeed, he can try before Hulk thunderclaps his ears.

this is H2H only..there's no need for intelligent or tactic here..if it's regular Supes..any normal person would give Hulk the win..but with a red ring..he's more bloodlust and can tank more attack than usual..it's just a punching contest..Supes will outlast Hulk..

At least, fighting smart (whilst not 'nerve pinching' Superman, at least a version of Supes that won't just go in flailing.

I dont think that lava is as impressive as the red napalm that the red lanterns use. Plus the hulks rage is just gonna make the ring stronger.