Darth Caedus and Darth Sidious VS. Yoda and Mace Windu

Who would win in a battle to the death!
Planet: Naboo - Place where Maul, Jinn, and Kenobi fought.

Caedus loses to either Windu or Yoda without question, leaving Sidious alone to face the only two Jedi that Lucas himself stated could, and did, take Sidious in saber combat. The Jedi win.

Caedus does not lose to Windu without question. That's not how this game works.

^ Or Yoda for that matter.

Yoda and Windu take this in a very close battle.

Originally posted by Ascendancy
leaving Sidious alone to face the only two Jedi that Lucas himself stated could, and did, take Sidious in saber combat. The Jedi win.

facepalm He never said that about "Saber" combat.

Spoiler:
The poster who told you that has a habit of twisting quotes to mean anything he desires them to.

Originally posted by Zampanó
Caedus does not lose to Windu without question. That's not how this game works.

In my opinion, he would lose to Windu or Yoda. It would not be easily, but nor does he have a great shot at beating them.

I disagree because Jacen's feats and abilities might allow him to kill Yoda or Windu, despite Yoda or Windu's own feats and abilities.

(Argument forthcoming within 16 hours.)

Such as? Jacen's greatest feat was defeating the Jedi Strike team while recovering. While Kyle Katarn is a certifiable badass, he is by no account a top-tier Jedi. He has little in the way of usable feats.

Other than that, his fight with Luke was barely viable for use in a thread and he was handled by the decidedly less-powerful Mara Jade.

Team one wins.

Well, Yoda will again go toe-to-toe with Sidious and this fight will drag out.

However, Windu possesses major advantage over Caedus—Vaapad. If he managed to hand Sidious his ass with it, I see no reason why he should not do the same to a Sith Lord less powerful than Sids.

I would just like to say that Vaapad is one of the dumbest ideas of an EU teeming with dumb ideas.

Yep, but it is what it is....

Originally posted by axel_jovan
Yep, but it is what it is....

Seriously, it's something that could be found in the second KotOR game. Dark, overly complicated, and ultimately retarded. You feed off the dark energy around you and let it fountain back out again, tapping into your inner wellspring of darkness, it's a way of life, blah blah.

I'd rebuke Stover had he not already expressed his personal dislike of Vaapad and lightsaber forms in general.

Vaapad gives the Jedi a high difficulty win. Assuming that Windu feeds off both siths energies.

Mace Windu was a beast, but so was Caedus. Team 1 could pull it off because of Sidious, and the fact that Caedus far outclassed human Vader in ROTS.