ROTJ Luke Skywalker Vs Qui Gon Jinn

Well since there has been alot of talk here about ROTJ Lukes power I was wondering how stronger everyone places him. He's taking on a powerful Jedi Master who would have been on the council had it not been for his rebelious nature.

IMO Luke stomps this. He was able to defeat Vader and Vader in sabers >>>> Jinn so.

I doubt it. There is no chance for ROTJ Luke to stopm.

Originally posted by Zett
I doubt it. There is no chance for ROTJ Luke to stopm.

Agreed. Luke doesn't stomp this. Unlike Vader, Jinn is an acrobatic fighter who would not just stand around while Luke pounds him. Luke could still possibly win, but his lack of Jedi experience holds him back.

Originally posted by Vensai
Agreed. Luke doesn't stomp this. Unlike Vader, Jinn is an acrobatic fighter who would not just stand around while Luke pounds him. Luke could still possibly win, but his lack of Jedi experience holds him back.

Luke beat Vader who would on QGJ in seconds.

Originally posted by ROTJ Vader
Luke beat Vader who would on QGJ in seconds.

Vader was trying to turn Luke to the dark side. Nor did he use his TK against him like in their first duel. Vader would waste Luke in a TK duel.

I'd still vote for Luke, but he's in no way unscathed in this battle.