Gandalf the White (movie) vs. Ganondorf (TP)

Started by NotAllThatEvil30 pages

What has movie gandalf even done? A bit of telekinesis and breaking a rock? Book G has a chance but movie gandalf isn't exactly the amazing sorcerer a lot of people make him out to be...

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
What has movie gandalf even done? A bit of telekinesis and breaking a rock? Book G has a chance but movie gandalf isn't exactly the amazing sorcerer a lot of people make him out to be...
You exaggerate Ganondorf greatly. Killed a Balrog.

He dropped in a lake. The fall and the water did most of the work. What has gandalf actually done?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
He dropped in a lake. The fall and the water did most of the work. What has gandalf actually done?
No, it Didnt. Gandalf did so.

So besides dropping the fire monster into a lake, what has gandalf done?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
So besides dropping the fire monster into a lake, what has gandalf done?
He stabbed the Balrog and bested him that way. Saruman defeat, tk blast which floored hundreds of enemies, blocked a Legolas arrow at close range, and burned Aragorn's sword.

He lost to saruman, I gave you Telekinesis, ganondorf blocked arrows too, when did he burn Aragorn's sword?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
He lost to saruman, I gave you Telekinesis, ganondorf blocked arrows too, when did he burn Aragorn's sword?
Gandalf the White beat him. Right after he blocked arrow. Same scene. No, gameplay mechanic. Different, fanboy.

I distinctly remember an elf putting an arrow in his chest... oh well. Sorry, I thought you were talking about his big RotK sword. Sorry for using a game to talk about a game character. Considering WW, TP, and OoT ganondorf could do it, I figured it was canon.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
I distinctly remember an elf putting an arrow in his chest... oh well. Sorry, I thought you were talking about his big RotK sword. Sorry for using a game to talk about a game character. Considering WW, TP, and OoT ganondorf could do it, I figured it was canon.
Concession accepted.

An apology is not aconcession. Ganondorf could still survive a castle falling on him and can patch lacerations up with magic. Heating ganondorf's sword might not even work as it's not made of metal and I stand by him blocking arrows. You can't ONLY use cutscenes when debating a video game.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
An apology is not aconcession. Ganondorf could still survive a castle falling on him and can patch lacerations up with magic. Heating ganondorf's sword might not even work as it's not made of metal and I stand by him blocking arrows. You can't ONLY use cutscenes when debating a video game.

You could go solely by cutscenes and Gandalf still couldn't win here because Ganon tanked Midna's spear.
Originally posted by quanchi112
You do not even understand your own logic.

No, mirror did. Speculation.

Baseless claims.

Balrog is superior than someone who is easily cut into such as Dorf.


Just because it escapes you doesn't mean you need to throw a tantrum.

Ganondorf is not easily cut, Midna hit him with a spear with enough force to blow his castle up, this did not even harm him. Gandalf cannot harm him.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
You could go solely by cutscenes and Gandalf still couldn't win here because Ganon tanked Midna's spear.

Just because it escapes you doesn't mean you need to throw a tantrum.

Ganondorf is not easily cut, Midna hit him with a spear with enough force to blow his castle up, this did not even harm him. Gandalf cannot harm him.

Sages and Link did so.

Speculation. We don't know. What we do know is swords cut into him.

... and then he patches it with magic...

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
... and then he patches it with magic...
Gandalf is stabbing him. Ganondorf sits back and has to wait for it to happen. He cannot defend himself.

'K. But being stabbed is probably thr least efficient way for gandalf to kill him.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Sages and Link did so.

Speculation. We don't know. What we do know is swords cut into him.


The sages did not cut Ganon with the ToP, Link is much stronger than Gandalf and his sword is much more powerful than Glamdring.

Castle buster > Gandalf.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
The sages did not cut Ganon with the ToP, Link is much stronger than Gandalf and his sword is much more powerful than Glamdring.

Castle buster > Gandalf.

Link did. Sages bfr defeated Dorf with top.

Swords cut him. Already proven. 🙂

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
'K. But being stabbed is probably thr least efficient way for gandalf to kill him.
It works.

Assuming he doesn't take gandalf's sword like he did the sages and blitzes the wizard. Yeah if he just stood there while gandalf cut him at least a dozen times, then yeah it works.