Team Mk/Harry Potter vs. Team LOZ/Lotr

Started by quanchi11220 pages

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
So yes, the manga is canon. Concession accepted.
You haven't proven it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You haven't proven it.
Originally posted by ScreamPaste
"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

Direct quote from Eiji Aonuma. The manga is part of Hyrule Historia.

Eiji himself was chief editor and guided the entire process of the book's creation. Hyrule Historia is canon.


Pardon? Counter or concede.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Pardon? Counter or concede.
Burden is on you.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Burden is on you.
Then you concede.
Originally posted by ScreamPaste
"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

Direct quote from Eiji Aonuma. The manga is part of Hyrule Historia.

Eiji himself was chief editor and guided the entire process of the book's creation. Hyrule Historia is canon.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Then you concede.
That isn't proof.

"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

Look. Proof.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

Look. Proof.

That isn't proof.

Yes it is, because Eiji Aonuma said it.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Yes it is, because Eiji Aonuma said it.
When did he say it was canon ?

That's the great part, he doesn't need to because you agree HH is canon.

"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

If HH is canon, the manga is canon.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
That's the great part, he doesn't need to because you agree HH is canon.

"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

If HH is canon, the manga is canon.

Where does he say its canon ?

Is HH canon?

"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

If it is, the manga is then canon. Because they're both part of the same thing.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Is HH canon?

"This book is organized in four big sections. The first one, “The
First Story,” is an introduction to the new game Skyward Sword; the
second chapter, “The Full History of Hyrule,” follows the order of
events of the Zelda series chronologically; the third section,
“Creative Traces,” presents artwork from past games, including some
rough sketches; and the fourth part is a special manga by Akira
Himekawa, the leading author in charge of creating the manga of the
Zelda series."

If it is, the manga is then canon. Because they're both part of the same thing.

Manga isn't canon. Get over it. Crying about it isn't going to change it.

What exactly is your definition of canon?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Manga isn't canon. Get over it. Crying about it isn't going to change it.

Stop dodging the question.

Is HH Canon? Yes or no. If you do not answer this you're avoiding the point and concede it by default.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
What exactly is your definition of canon?
In continuity.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Stop dodging the question.

Is HH Canon? Yes or no. If you do not answer this you're avoiding the point and concede it by default.

Manga isnt but rest is.

You dodged the question, as I said, you concede by default. Fine with me.

Originally posted by quanchi112
In continuity.

Well as the manga tells the origin of the goddess sword and skyloft, wouldn't that fit within the continuity?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Well as the manga tells the origin of the goddess sword and skyloft, wouldn't that fit within the continuity?
No, since it isn't canon.