Achilles vs. Gauntlet

I disagree, I think alot of those characters are in his overall level, some below, some above. I think the list is out of order, personally, but its a good solid list for opponents for movie Achilles.

Originally posted by The_Raven_1401
This thread is a joke.

The movie Achilles, while not invulnerable, is constantly talked about as one the greatest ever fighters. No one comes even close to hurting him in melee combat. He absolutely destroys his closest rival, who was himself a legendary warrior.

Most of the fighters on the list wouldn't last 5 seconds.
Aragorn might be a much more honourable, likeable guy, but he isn't considered a legendary deadly warrior in the books or the films. He struggle to kill one orc leader, and got battered by a troll. Book version has even less impressive combat feats. He was a great leader of men, not a melee powerhouse.

Gregor clegane, book or movie version, would be cutting air the entire fight. He was embarrassed by a 50 year old viper. Achilles would utterly destroy him.

Maximum etc aren't even close. Legolas? Are you all mental? The while point of Achilles was that he was an f-ing unstoppable fighting machine. Save a surprised ranged melee attack, it'd take someone far better than those on the list to even challenge him.

Book Achilles kills them all at the same time, and skull crushes Gregor.

Good assessment +1

Originally posted by Robtard
1) Wins. is bloodied
2) Wins, but is bloodied with a loose anus
3) Loses
4) Loses
5) Loses, not a film char
6) Loses
7) Wins
8) Wins, not a film char
9) Loses
10) Loses
12) Wins
13) Loses

Your list is very reasonable, but just wondering... why do you think Aragorn win? it's been a long time since I watched the LotR movies, and I can't honestly remember anything really impresive from Aragorn, skillswise.