Warriors Madness Thor has an Odin enchanted, Uru, Katana...

Lets think back to Blood and Thunder and Warriors Madness Thor...

Lets imagine for a second, that Thor did not have Mjolnir, but had an Uru Katana that possessed all of Mjolnirs enchantments...

Now given Thors blood lust, he would definitely be weilding this Uru Katana with lethal intent...

So with all of that being said, how does the story unfold if Thor has an enchanted Uru Katana instead of Mjolnir? For example, Beta Ray Bill might be killed eariler in the arc if Thor han an enchanted Uru Katana instead of Mjolnir (I am imagining the scene in issue 1 where Thor slams Mjolnir down on a defenseless Bill; if that was a Katana instead, Bill would have been sliced in half)...

If Thor has this Uru Katana, how does the Thanos fight go down? Does he slice Thanos in half or behead him? Is Thanos forced to run grab his weapon sooner than he did when Thor had Mjolnir? What about the initial fight with the Infinty Watch; do they all die (except Pip, who would certainly flee) when confronting Warriors Madness Thor with an enchanted Uru Katana?

What do you think? How does Blood and Thunder go down if Thor had an enchanted Uru Katana with all of Mjolnirs enchantments placed upon it?

Thor has very limited time experience with katana fighting, this is a downgrading honestly

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Thor has very limited time experience with katana fighting, this is a downgrading honestly

Limited compared to his time with Mjolnir perhaps, but he is Asgardian; he is skilled with all sorts of melee weapons...

He'd be able to fight effectively with it as a result...

Scans for Kendo training

Katana skills /=/ Broad sword skills

It's two different styles completely...

So is this just a pissed off Thor with an Uru Katana? Or Pissed off Thor with Power Gem and an Uru Katana?

If it's a) Thor gets beat down...........hard. If it's b) Thor gets BFRed by force block like last time.

Thanos wins.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Scans for Kendo training

Katana skills /=/ Broad sword skills

It's two different styles completely...

You are spliting hairs and taking away from the spirit of the thread; the thread assumes that he'd be able to weild the Uru Katana with skill equal to that in which he weilds Mjolnir...

Now...care to comment on how Blood and Thunder would have gone down under these conditions?

Ok, if Thor wanted them dead he could have killed them with Mjoinir, I can't really see it playing out any differently tbh...

Originally posted by zopzop
So is this just a pissed off Thor with an Uru Katana? Or Pissed off Thor with Power Gem and an Uru Katana?

If it's a) Thor gets beat down...........hard. If it's b) Thor gets BFRed by force block like last time.

Thanos wins.

My question is how does the arc in its entirety go down if Thor had an Uru Katana instead of Mjolnir...

In regards to the Thanos fight, Thor had the Power Gem when he got to Thanos, so yeah...he has the Gem when he battles Thanos.

Remember this though; Thor got in close and scored several strikes with Mjolnir against Thanos...now imagine that he was slicing Thanos with a weapon sharper and deadlier than Adamantium (and Adamantium slices through Thanos).

Do you really think Thanos just casually wins? Is he forced to go to his weapon much faster than when he actually did go to it? Or does Thor slice him limb from limb?

This OP just wants to you say what he wants to hear

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
My question is how does the arc in its entirety go down if Thor had an Uru Katana instead of Mjolnir...

In regards to the Thanos fight, Thor had the Power Gem when he got to Thanos, so yeah...he has the Gem when he battles Thanos.

Remember this though; Thor got in close and scored several strikes with Mjolnir against Thanos...now imagine that he was slicing Thanos with a weapon sharper than Adamantium (And Adamantium slices through Thanos).

Do you really think Thanos just casually wins? Is he forced to go to his weapon much faster than when he actually did go to it? Or does Thor slice him limb from limb?

If PG enhanced Thor's Mjolnir strikes didn't crush Thanos' bones to dust, then he's not doing any better with an Uru Katana in terms of slashing damage.

Thanos BFR force blocks him like last time before he draws too much power from the Gem.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Ok, if Thor wanted them dead he could have killed them with Mjoinir, I can't really see it playing out any differently tbh...

Why wouldnt it play out any differently? Thor definitely was trying to kill in that arc (he was about to kill Warlock when Warlock mentally summoned the Surfers surfboard to save himself and Surfer)...

Imagine Thor slicing Warlock instead of just blunt force bashing him...you dont think Warlock dies?

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Why wouldnt it play out any differently? Thor definitely was trying to kill in that arc (he was about to kill Warlock when Warlock mentally summoned the Surfers surfboard to save himself and Surfer)...

Imagine Thor slicing Warlock instead of just blunt force bashing him...you dont think Warlock dies?

If pissed off Mjolnir strikes from Thor didn't break bones, why would an uru katana slice off limbs?

Originally posted by xJLxKing
This OP just wants to you say what he wants to hear

No...I want a well thought out rational response instead of a knee-jerk response.

Originally posted by zopzop
Again who can say?

If pissed off Mjolnir strikes from Thor didn't break bones, why would an uru katana slice off limbs?

Why wouldnt it?

The weapon would be sharper than Primary Adamantium and also be enchanted by Odin; this weapon would be very lethal...

I see it like Wolvies Claws...only much worse given Thors strength and lethal intent given his state of mind.

Surely you arent arguing that Warlock cant be sliced by a weapon superior to Primary Adamantium being weilded by an insane Class 100 brick...

If Wolvie had Class 100 strength would he be able to slice Warlock up? You know fully well what the answer to that is...

@zopzop

Keep in mind that Wolverine already sliced through Thanos with Primary Adamantium and he doesnt possess 1/100th of the strength of Thor...

Also keep in mind that Uru enchanted by Odin is harder than Primary Adamantium...

With that in mind, you cant possibly believe that it would play out the exact same; any blow Thor connects on to any character in that arc is going to cut right though them...especially if his blows land flush as they did during Blood and Thunder.

If Thor hit Warlock full force he would splattered him with Mjoinir tbf

Thor's very skilled with the blade

Originally posted by pym-ftw
If Thor hit Warlock full force he would splattered him with Mjoinir tbf

Sans PIS, of course he would...

In a forum fight thats what would happen, but in the actual comic, its not allowed; for the purposes of this thread, Blood and Thunder goes down exactly like it did in the comic, but under forum conditions...

Thus no PIS..

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Katana skills /=/ Broad sword skills

It's two different styles completely...

That's true I guess