Thor Vs Alan Scott

1. Battle Thor vs Alan Scott
2. Battle Pre-Reigning King Thor vs Sentinel "Green Flame" Scott
3. Battle Rune King Thor vs Star-heart Alan Scott

Pre Flash point Alan
Classic/Current Thor

1.) Thor.
2.) Depends on which King Thor we're talking.
3.) Thor.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
1.) Thor.
2.) Depends on which King Thor we're talking.
3.) Thor.

What would you suggest, I want the fight to interesting not a megash** stomp!! I was thinking more before the Reigning

Yeah, late game King Thor would massacre Alan. I think King Thor early in the Reigning would be a good match for him.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Yeah, late game King Thor would massacre Alan. I think King Thor early in the Reigning would be a good match for him.

revamped

Alan with full starheart wins. Current loses.

Which showings or feats convince you of that by chance?

His feats in robibsons jla.

During The Dark Things arc/crossover with the JSA?

It was cool, mainly how he used constructs to distract the teams as he just sat there on his throne to deal with Fate and Faust, but that would't put him the level at or beyond RKT, imho.

Originally posted by the Darkone

1. Battle Thor vs Alan Scott
2. Battle Pre-Reigning King Thor vs Sentinel "Green Flame" Scott
3. Battle Rune King Thor vs Star-heart Alan Scott

Pre Flash point Alan
Classic/Current Thor

Thor slight edge
Edge to Alan
Thor solidly

Thor in all three.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
During The Dark Things arc/crossover with the JSA?

It was cool, mainly how he used constructs to distract the teams as he just sat there on his throne to deal with Fate and Faust, but that would't put him the level at or beyond RKT, imho.

He was battling the teams while he was on the moon. Took the shots of Power Girl and Supergirl and was laughing, mentally took control over a lot of people, and fought Mordru after or before the story. He was clearly skyfather plus, IMO.

Originally posted by Golgo13
He was battling the teams while he was on the moon. Took the shots of Power Girl and Supergirl and was laughing, mentally took control over a lot of people, and fought Mordru after or before the story. He was clearly skyfather plus, IMO.

Skyfather+?

RKT is definitely in that range. And Alan's feats, while nice, wouldn't put him at or above Odin level, which is what he'd have to be to beat Thor.

Yep, IMO he was that level, while bloodlusted.

Originally posted by Golgo13
Yep, IMO he was that level, while bloodlusted.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?

Nimoy being a better Spock than Quinto.