Pre DCnU Blue Devil was getting close to Etrigans normal level soo I could see it going either way but will vote for My Bad Boy Ettie on his sheer bad ass evilness in a fight to take it for the win.
BEA
beatboksready for the loony bin
without his trident Etrigan takes it. with it he has a good shot, Etrigan himself said the trident was powerful enough that with it he could take over hell