Black Panther vs. Black Manta

Started by Galan0074 pages

Originally posted by vansonbee
What happen? Got scans?
Aquaman vs. Black Manta (1/2):

Aquaman vs. Black Manta (2/2):

Im never quite sure what level Manta is supposed to be on.

Roughly Kingpin level, his longtime Marvel rival.

Originally posted by Zack M
Manta just defeated Aquaman in a pure fight.

Aquaman clearly did not lose the fight shown above by Galan. I hope you were referring to another recent one.

He's in the get his ass kicked by Black Panther tier.

Originally posted by Supermutant
Aquaman clearly did not lose the fight shown above by Galan. I hope you were referring to another recent one.

I thought he got the best of him, but didn't he cut off Aquaman's hand not too long ago under Johns. Either way, he did go to to toe with him and I don't see panther owning Manta at all.

Originally posted by Zack M
I thought he got the best of him, but didn't he cut off Aquaman's hand not too long ago under Johns. Either way, he did go to to toe with him and I don't see panther owning Manta at all.

Going toe to toe for a while against an opponent isn't the same thing as defeating that opponent, which is what you stated. Anyways it's not like Black Panther has routinely gone toe to toe with a class 100 Atlantean who can fly and has super speed. Oh wait 😛

Originally posted by Supermutant
Going toe to toe for a while against an opponent isn't the same thing as defeating that opponent, which is what you stated. Anyways it's not like Black Panther has routinely gone toe to toe with a class 100 Atlantean who can fly and has super speed. Oh wait 😛

His skills and stats mean he won't get owned by panther like some of you are saying. Even pre Flashpoint manta had stats near Aquaman, who owned deathstroke.

Originally posted by Zack M
I thought he got the best of him, but didn't he cut off Aquaman's hand not too long ago under Johns. Either way, he did go to to toe with him and I don't see panther owning Manta at all.

Yes. In Brightest day

Originally posted by Zack M
His skills and stats mean he won't get owned by panther like some of you are saying. Even pre Flashpoint manta had stats near Aquaman, who owned deathstroke.

Correct. Pre 52 underwent an experiment that merged his Dna with Aquaman and granted him atlantean abilities

Originally posted by Zack M
I thought he got the best of him

You also thought Midnighter looked fine against Grayson 😂

Manta did well against Aquaman, honestly.

Arthur only gained the definitive edge when he used the Trident.

yeah that was a very impressive showing no doubt. this is a tough call tbh. no one is sweeping. like most bp threads of late it may just come down to what gear you see him carrying. /shrug

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
You also thought Midnighter looked fine against Grayson 😂

😂 He looked superior.

Originally posted by Galan007
Manta did well against Aquaman, honestly.

Arthur only gained the definitive edge when he used the Trident.

👆

Originally posted by Zack M
His skills and stats mean he won't get owned by panther like some of you are saying. Even pre Flashpoint manta had stats near Aquaman, who owned deathstroke.

I never said BP would stomp him. You stated that Black Manta defeated Aquaman recently which he didn't. Moreover, Black Manta should give Aquaman a hard time, as that is his arch-nemesis and his gear is designed to combat him.

My point is that proves nothing when BP performs just as good against Namor if not better depending on his gear. Plus BP has much greater resources and feats with prep.

And if current BP is still KOTD he has much better gear to win this a good majority of the time.

Originally posted by Supermutant
I never said BP would stomp him. You stated that Black Manta defeated Aquaman recently which he didn't. Moreover, Black Manta should give Aquaman a hard time, as that is his arch-nemesis and his gear is designed to combat him.

My point is that proves nothing when BP performs just as good against Namor if not better depending on his gear. Plus BP has much greater resources and feats with prep.

And if current BP is still KOTD he has much better gear to win this a good majority of the time.

Well, is current Panther still KOTD? I'd still give Manta over standard Panther.

Originally posted by Zack M
Well, is current Panther still KOTD? I'd still give Manta over standard Panther.
he is still king of the dead

Originally posted by Zack M
😂 He looked superior.

He got lucky that he hurt Dick while countering his Spyral tech 😉

But no, if any superiority MN has shown, it was marginal. Don't make Galan repost the scans and embarrass you again in the same thread.