Companions of the Hall vs. The Fellowship of the Ring

Two of the best groups of fantasy heroes in literary history.

Companions of the Hall:
- Drizzt Do'Urden - legendary drow ranger, who wields twin scimitars, holds a statue that summons his panther companion, Guenhwyvar, to a battlefield, wears enchanted anklets to speed his footwork to keep up with his already blinding hand speed with his scimitars.
- Bruenor Battlehammer - Eighth, and Tenth King of Mithral Hall. Wields a many-notched axe, each notch representing a kill. While not overly quick, he is still a fierce fighter, making up for his lack of speed with his ferocity
- Catti-Brie - Adopted daughter of Bruenor. Her main weapon of choice is Taulmaril the Heartseeker, a bow which pin-points a target's heart, and, when fired, arrows become like lightning bolts, and the quiver magically refills. She also wields the sword Khazid-hea, also known as Cutter, a sentient sword that has a great desire for blood, and takes control of weak-minded wielders (Catti-brie is not so).
- Wulfgar - Nearly 7' tall Barbarian, and adopted son of Bruenor. He is able to take multiple, small wounds without noticing, and is among the strongest individuals in all of Toril, even lifting opponents (with easily 100lbs on him) over his head with ease. He wields Aegis-fang, an enchanted warhammer forged by Bruenor Battlehammer, if thrown, it will return to his hand upon his mental call.
- Regis Underwood - a hobbit, or Halfling, who isn't much for combat, but wields a small mace and an enchanted ruby which, when spun in front of an enemy, can enthrall them and make them respond with utter loyalty to his commands.

For the Fellowship of the Ring, I don't believe I really need to give a description of each member, since this group is far more well known, but I am leaving Gandalf out of the equation, since it would offer the Fellowship an advantage with magic, as well as numbers:
- Aragorn
- Frodo Baggins
- Samwise Gamgee
- Merry Brandybuck
- Pippin Took
- Legolas
- Gimli
- Boromir

Quick Edit:

The Fellowship is the book version, not the movies.

Not familiar with the Companions but judging by your description, I don't see the Fellowship lasting 2 minutes. I mean a friggin sword that summons panthers!

It's a statue, not a sword, but that's all details.

Do you think I should've kept Gandalf in this?

I guess but its only a matter of seconds till one of the Companions shoves him over and breaks his hip.

Originally posted by COG Veteran
I guess but its only a matter of seconds till one of the Companions shoves him over and breaks his hip.

Ah. Forgot the Balrog fight. *faceknife*

Leaning towads Fellowship, only if they have him tho.

Lol'd my dick off at "*faceknife*". Hahahahahahaha! haermm

So what I'm hearing is a general consensus that Gandalf should be in this fight, so screw it...I'll throw him into this just to give the Fellowship a fighting chance.

The thing is that Gandalf is so much more powerful than the rest of the Fellowship that this becomes "Gandalf vs. Companions of the Hall".

He actually might be powerful enough to solo. It would require a fairly powerful spellcaster to take out Gandalf.

This is a rather difficult scenario imo. Either the Companions of the hall rips the Fellowship apart, or the fellowship gets Gandalf and rips the Companions apart. Gandalf from the books was just ... nasty.

Um. No he wasn't. Unless we are using hypothetical full power Gandalf I see no way that he is soloing this.

If we are actually using the Maia Gandalf, and not the "I'm supposed to help but not interfere to much" Gandalf, imo he can take this. Call it Full power Gandalf if you like.

Except, we have never seen what he is able to do. It's complete speculation.

But Gandalf, as he is presented in LotR, stands no chance at soloing.

If you're limiting him to that then I think whoever the hell the Companions are have the victory in the fairly mismatched fight. Of course it does seem to be pretty mismatched either way.

Originally posted by ares834
Except, we have never seen what he is able to do. It's complete speculation.

But Gandalf, as he is presented in LotR, stands no chance at soloing.

We have seen what the rest of his race of Maia can do, that should suffice, imo. But to each his own.

Agreed.

Originally posted by MooCowofJustice
If you're limiting him to that then I think whoever the hell the Companions are have the victory in the fairly mismatched fight. Of course it does seem to be pretty mismatched either way.

Read RA Salvatore's Legend of Drizzt series to find out who they are.

Originally posted by Utrigita
We have seen what the rest of his race of Maia can do, that should suffice, imo. But to each his own.

Not really. The thing about magic in LotR is that it's typically not all the combat applicable. Yeah, it's powerful but when an army comes for Sauron he surrenders rather than start hurling fireballs. And, later on, Sauron is slain by Elendil and Gil-Galad in direct combat.

Originally posted by ares834
Not really. The thing about magic in LotR is that it's typically not all the combat applicable. Yeah, it's powerful but when an army comes for Sauron he surrenders rather than start hurling fireballs. And, later on, Sauron is slain by Elendil and Gil-Galad in direct combat.

Gandalf solo'd a Balrog, a CR20 creature, and he did it while at his weakest.

He ragestomps all over Drizzt and his gang of metrosexuals.