Mr. Majestic vs. Beta Ray Bill

Started by leonidas2 pages

@rage. you mentioned there was an instance where the blades were broken--do you happen to know where that is? what IS the relative strength of the blades? i ask cuz i don't recall seeing them broken, and always assumed they were uber durable--enough to block high end energy anyway, or cut it away (galan showed that scan i think....?)

i'm still not getting why you think lopping off a limb would be something beyond the blade. i don't think you believe the blade would....break? before it completed its cut, do you? so, what exactly would impede its progress? not lack of strength, obviously, or speed. its edge is uber sharp--sharper than say, logan's claws? if the electron comment was NOT hyperbole (maybe you think it was?) then the blades are likely SHARPER than logan's claws (or at the very least AS SHARP). i think if we gave maj loagn's claws, and extended them by 2ft, he could certainly cut off bill's head with them. i get you've never seen the blades do it, but that doesn't mean they would be incapable of doing so. i guess i'm just not getting exactly the WHY you think the blades would fail. i'm also curious--which do you feel is more likely--bill would use his speed to DEFEND against maj's speed, or maj's speed would prove too great for bill to counter. i'm thinking that most think thor/superman could go either way, or is at least pretty dern close. i wonder how people would view it if supes were given a blade that can shave electrons and was uber durable? surely the blades would add wins to the superman camp, no?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I assume all of them are forged by his people's technology although that can't be proven. I however don’t assume that all of them are exact replicas or can match anything one blade does. For example, the blade he used in that scene was morphing into different shapes and was noticeably bigger. This clearly implies that it's different/superior to the slim and extremely sharp Kusar blade he's more prone to using.
It was still 'a' Kusar blade, is what I'm saying.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I get what you’re saying. I however strongly disagree it’s enough of a jump to assume clean decapitations or limp removals in a fight.

Which is about all I see Majestic doing with his sword.

Wow, oookay...

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Trying to give Majestic Superman level abilities across the board and giving his swords feats that don’t apply to them is somehow different than using Thor as a baseline for Beta Ray Bill? 😬 Whatever you say.
By all accounts Majestic is Superman-level across the board. Would Superman win a forum battle? Likely so(he's got thousands more feats, after all), but that doesn't change the fact that they are still peers-- heck, even Majestic's DC bio says that his strength/invulnerability rivals Superman's. /shrug

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I get what you’re saying and he was near Skuttlebutt, but he wasn’t on its surface by the time he struck Surfer. Not to mention we have other feats that establish Bill’s reflexes as being right up there with nano-second perception.
Bill was already moving FTL because he was atop Skuttlebutt. Therefore, him tagging FTL Surfer isn't nearly as impressive as you think, because they were traveling roughly the same speed at the time.

...And this scan wasn't really clear-cut, imo:
http://i673.photobucket.com/albums/vv95/galanphotos/brb_surfer2.jpg
We can't even see Bill's feet, so I'm not sure why you think he jumped..? To me, it looks like he simply adjusted his stance when he delivered the strikes.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Not really sure what Kusar blades would do to aid Majestic from a distance but if they were up close and trading blows, then heat vision would probably hit their mark. But so would a giant lightning bolt to Majestic’s face and they would be noticeably more devastating against Majestros then heat vision would be against Bill with his massive heat/energy resistance.
Majestic's HV was capable of instantly altering Jupiter's entire structure at the pre-atomic level, it pierced right through Fortress Mode Eradicator's armor/shielding, etc. Bill isn't just tanking that.