Originally posted by KingD19
I enjoyed Silent Hill more because they didn't try to do a direct adaptation of the games because of how complicated they are. They kept it vague and made their own story for a movie audience and had Pyramid Head pulling people's skin off. It was a fun action horror romp.
For me, it was also the first adaptation to really capture the "feel" of the games. Both before and after the sirens felt very much like the first time I played through the first Silent Hill game.