Spiderman (Andrew Garfield) vs. Spiderman (Tobey Maguire)

Which Spiderman wins in a fight, using movie feats?

Well Tobey/Spidey fought more villains so stands to reason he'd have more battle skills to take down Garfield.

By the time ASM 2 comes out, Andrew Spidy should win. The trailers showed him to be uber fast and strong.

Agreed the trailer alone showed Garfield having accurate speed and strength.
Though Tobey feats are still insane. Time will tell and no one is jumping the gun on this one.

I believe Tobey's Spider-Man had damage soak like taking a goblin-bomb with no real injury where as Garfield's Spider-Man was slowed down by a bullet to the leg.

Tobey wins for now no matter what.
Having his legs splinter train rail sleepers/crossties is an insane feat.
And is just one of the proven feats why the Tobey version has durability and strength over his Garfield counterpart.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Tobey wins for now no matter what.
Having his legs splinter train rail sleepers/crossties is an insane feat.
And is just one of the proven feats why the Tobey version has durability and strength over his Garfield counterpart.

👆

ASM needs to take a bomb to face to earn my respect