Middle Earth vs. Westeros vs. Narnia

Started by quanchi11213 pagesPoll

Who prevails ?

Middle Earth vs. Westeros vs. Narnia

Movie versions and tv version only. Each side has two weeks to comprise effective battle strategies as they go to war. No ghosts. Only physical characters in this thread.

I know very little about Narnia, but I'm pretty sure ME is stronger than Westeros.

Originally posted by ArtificialGlory
I know very little about Narnia, but I'm pretty sure ME is stronger than Westeros.
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe was very well done.

I don't think Narnia has anything of worth besides the Witch (whose name is lost on me) and Jesus-lion.

Jesus Lion is a bona fide pocket dimension buster at the very least and can tell time what to do.

But as Quan is making this movie version only I can't remember anything good from Aslan there(he logically still created Narnia and such).

Originally posted by BloodRain
I don't think Narnia has anything of worth besides the Witch (whose name is lost on me) and Jesus-lion.
You need to watch the movies again if you feel like Narnia is of no consequence.

I voted Narnia

Originally posted by quanchi112
You need to watch the movies again if you feel like Narnia is of no consequence.
Eh, the animals and people weren't that fearsome.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Eh, the animals and people weren't that fearsome.
The magic and what not definitely was. The armies were pretty impressive and can compete here. You act as if this army can't keep up with Westeros.

What was the most notable magic they had, besides the witch? They were impressive but lacking in power. And Westeros? IIRC the show so far has only shown two dozen Walkers and 3 teen dragons? Otherwise just strong humans, right?

Don't know anything about Narnia, but Middle Earth would crush Westeros. Unless there's some OP magical shenanigans, High Fantasy usually shits on Low/dark fantasy settings.

Originally posted by BloodRain
What was the most notable magic they had, besides the witch? They were impressive but lacking in power. And Westeros? IIRC the show so far has only shown two dozen Walkers and 3 teen dragons? Otherwise just strong humans, right?
Lion, dragon, Witch, etc.

So your thing is to dismiss armies so matter of factor. Hilarious since Zelda games rarely if ever demonstrate an effective army.

Middle Earth. Narnia doesn't have the numbers, and Westeros is mostly untrained peasants.

Middle Earth has Smaug.

/thread

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lion, dragon, Witch, etc.

So your thing is to dismiss armies so matter of factor. Hilarious since Zelda games rarely if ever demonstrate an effective army.

This isnt a Zelda thread. Keep up.

See, you're just agreeing with me. Theres barely any power in Narnia besides a few, and that power wont be enough. I have full permission to dismiss an army when its outclassed by the opposition.

LOTR stomps

Originally posted by BloodRain
This isnt a Zelda thread. Keep up.

See, you're just agreeing with me. Theres barely any power in Narnia besides a few, and that power wont be enough. I have full permission to dismiss an army when its outclassed by the opposition.

But the same applies to them. Random nobodies with no real armies or organization.

Narnia has armies and a few beings with massive power. The difference is you seem to believe certain characters from your beloved franchise can solo despite proof to the contrary.

Ser Gregor Clegane chokeslams Sauron and breaks Aslan's back over his knee.

Is this a race to see which side beats Hyrule the fastest?

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Is this a race to see which side beats Hyrule the fastest?
You are starting to catch on.