Supergirl vs Wonder Woman

Yeah, she makes meals faster.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Because you've shown a lack of objectivity when it comes to Wonder Woman.

The fact that this thread is still open means I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt. How long it stays open, is up to you.

FWIW in a normal fight I would give diana 6-7/10 on Kara, I think Kara is a bit stronger and more durable than her though. She would win here 6/10 IMO.

It was pretty difficult to find a consistent power level for SG and PG pre-Flashpoint.
Despite presenting the idea that SG only seemed uber relative to Superman because he held back, SG also seemed to drop in power level relative to other heroes post-original push.
Diana could not match Supergirl during her original push--Diana couldn't manhandle the league like SG did when she was Dark Supergirl. But on the whole WW was more often presented as being able to take SG in a fight.

Originally posted by Pillow Biter
It was pretty difficult to find a consistent power level for SG and PG pre-Flashpoint.
Despite presenting the idea that SG only seemed uber relative to Superman because he held back, SG also seemed to drop in power level relative to other heroes post-original push.
Diana could not match Supergirl during her original push--Diana couldn't manhandle the league like SG did when she was Dark Supergirl. But on the whole WW was more often presented as being able to take SG in a fight.

http://i.imgur.com/aRy4FC3.jpg

And beat Titans Tomorrow Superman who earlier caught a full punch from Kara like nothing and wtfpwned full powered Freddy Captain Marvel.

She also overpowered Brimstone casually when future wonder girl and current wonder girl were having trouble.

http://imgur.com/dDHSNlA
http://imgur.com/1Vgla8H
http://imgur.com/q1kyXNh

The same future wonder girl knocked wonder woman out albeit by an ambush.

Even in Final Crisis, wonder woman needed her skills to beat Black Mary.

http://i.imgur.com/7EglefN.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/TeSwJ8K.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/iNGujNQ.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/2on6Vb8.jpg

Stopping a punch by both hands? Lame.

Supergirl straight up overpowered her.

http://i.imgur.com/YnU3sEi.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/bDSutRx.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/6l6YgQv.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/L0oTYKY.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xkPi1oP.jpg

So I don't see how she was supposed to be below wonder woman level when she has actual wins over top tiers in h2h. Ultraman has oneshotted Wonder Woman last they met BTW.

http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/16706880/dianaowned.jpg.html

Yeah, no lack of objectivity here.

You should just probably avoid threads with Wonder Woman in them from now on, I'm thinking.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Yeah, no lack of objectivity here.

You should just probably avoid threads with Wonder Woman in them from now on, I'm thinking.

TBF there are some portrayals which point out that Wonder Woman IS more powerful/dangerous/effective than supergirl.

Zatanna outright said that Diana was the most powerful woman on the planet.

http://i.imgur.com/0zDax5R.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/bnK84mA.jpg

Same with Batman saying that she was the most dangerous among a group consisting of several GLs, Supergirl, Firestorm etc.

http://i.imgur.com/eVKFrcU.jpg

But power=/=strength.

Originally posted by abhilegend
What did I say that was wrong about wonder woman? I am just arguing that Kara was right there with wonder woman in terms of strength till the end albeit slightly stronger. Its not that she was in a different tier or something. I'm genuinely curious about this "lack of objectivity" now.

So I'm just supposed to forget about every other thread where you posted about Diana? Really?

And what about Ultraman? Was it not so long ago that you were arguing with someone about how the Ultraman that Kara beat up wasn't as impressive as the higher up Ultramans?

On average, I would say Kara was stronger, yes. Even for strength, some portrayals may imply an equality - or even superiority- for Wonder woman. But I'd say on the whole SG was stronger. That being said, formidability is more complex.

Originally posted by -Pr-
So I'm just supposed to forget about every other thread where you posted about Diana? Really?

And what about Ultraman? Was it not so long ago that you were arguing with someone about how the Ultraman that Kara beat up wasn't as impressive as the higher up Ultramans?

The first Ultraman in Supergirl series was a new character from Earth-3 but this Ultraman which Kara beat in Robinson's JLA was from crime syndicate aka antimatter universe. Don't worry though, Robinson wrote superman treating Supergirl as a spoiled child in strength.

Whenever WW directly goes against Supergirl or Power Girl, she comes out looking pretty good.

Heck, Power Girl punched her to *Canada* and she just shrugged it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Same with Batman saying that she was the most dangerous among a group consisting of several GLs, Supergirl, Firestorm etc.

http://i.imgur.com/eVKFrcU.jpg

She was the most "dangerous" because Batman couldn't focus with his cock hard, that's why.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
She was the most "dangerous" because Batman couldn't focus with his cock hard, that's why.

Then he should have asked Robin to leave the room.

There can be skill in a slugfest. how you take or roll with a punch is a skill in itself, and one WW has a vast advantage over Supergirl in.

WW stomps.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Aw c'mon pr, its ownage thread and I just stumbled upon a very good comic book archive.

The first Ultraman in Supergirl series was a new character from Earth-3 but this Ultraman which Kara beat in Robinson's JLA was from crime syndicate aka antimatter universe. Don't worry though, Robinson wrote superman treating Supergirl as a spoiled child in strength.

I know; I did read the comic, as shitty as it was.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Then he should have asked Robin to leave the room.

😂 I usually hate Batman pedo jokes, but dammit, that was funny.

Originally posted by Q99
Whenever WW directly goes against Supergirl or Power Girl, she comes out looking pretty good.

Heck, Power Girl punched her to *Canada* and she just shrugged it.

In the very same story she conceded that PG is at least as strong as her. In Waid's B&B PG looked solidly above her in strength with knocking her out and then catching her punch.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Power Girl owns wonder woman

After that easily catches her punch after Diana blindsided her

Although in the first fight Diana was somewhat poisoned, so its not totally fair. But catching her full punch is totally legit.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I know; I did read the comic, as shitty as it was.

😂 I usually hate Batman pedo jokes, but dammit, that was funny.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So, what did you think? She looked solidly above wonder woman's strength class there.

I think almost everything Robinson writes in DC is a gigantic, triceratops level pile of shit.

How is brave and bold a valid example, btw?

Originally posted by abhilegend
So, what did you think? She looked solidly above wonder woman's strength class there.

Looked pretty close. Blocking a shot doesn't indicate superior strength, and as you say, the first one was poisoned.

And considering PG > Supergirl, still goes to Diana in the Supergirl matchup.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I think almost everything Robinson writes in DC is a gigantic, triceratops level pile of shit.

How is brave and bold a valid example, btw?

Why it isn't? Its canon and all?

Originally posted by Q99
Looked pretty close. Blocking a shot doesn't indicate superior strength, and as you say, the first one was poisoned.

And considering PG > Supergirl, still goes to Diana in the Supergirl matchup.

😂

Who said PG>SG? Supergirl has way better feats than PG.