Well first because this should be in the video game forum, but the real problem is that the video game forum already has a Sephiroth vs. Link thread, which is 104 pages and currently locked.
You can read it here: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=504708
Originally posted by The Scenario
Well first because this should be in the video game forum, but the real problem is that the video game forum already has a Sephiroth vs. Link thread, which is 104 pages and currently locked.You can read it here: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=504708
How is this not cross genera when Sephiroth is from a movie, like this one? This meets cross genera criteria.
Originally posted by Supra
How is this not cross genera when Sephiroth is from a movie, like this one? This meets cross genera criteria.
Advent Children is part of the FFVII canon though so....
Yeah there's no way we're debating this again.
Originally posted by Nemesis X
Advent Children is part of the FFVII canon though so....Yeah there's no way we're debating this again.
Its up to Imp at this point as I have already contacted him, its his forum. You guys just don't want to debate about it so your crying about it not being cross genera when it clearly is.
Originally posted by Supra
Its up to Imp at this point as I have already contacted him, its his forum. You guys just don't want to debate about it so your crying about it not being cross genera when it clearly is.
Still shares the same world as the game which is something you don't seem to be quite grasping. If the movie Sephiroth is in were as different from the games as, say, the live action Resident Evil movies, you might have something but considering this Sephiroth is the same one, we're not interested for it'll just reopen old wounds. No offense.
Originally posted by Nemesis X
Still shares the same world as the game which is something you don't seem to be quite grasping. If the movie Sephiroth is in were as different from the games as, say, the live action Resident Evil movies, you might have something but considering this Sephiroth is the same one, we're not interested for it'll just reopen old wounds. No offense.
Why can't two gods of there own kingdoms who are master swordsmen here on a cross genera platform..your limiting a good debate.
Originally posted by Nemesis X
The debate on KMC started four years later after the movie's release, dude haermm
Was the debate about the movie or game, its about the game. This is about the movie. Glad you went back and matched dates of a game thread to a movie for me though, thanks and quit derailing the thread troll.
You've got a lot of nerve calling someone a troll, Supra. After all, you served a six day ban for doing just that. I highly recommend you stop with the attitude.
Now, as for the matter at hand, which versions of Sephiroth and Link are being debated here?
I have previously stated that cross genre means movie vs game, anime vs comic book, manga vs novel, etc.
True, Sephiroth originated from FFVII, a video game, but if the movie version ONLY wants to be used, then it is allowable. However, we must abide by the rule of screen feats only when discussing film. Sephiroth will not have materia or his god-like powers as seen in the game.
So, I ask again: Which version are we discussing here? After all, the rules CLEARLY state (See Rule #5) that the OP must define which versions are being used.
FYI, I agree with Nemesis; this has been done to death.