The Dog was confirmed to be The Presence multiple times(not just the Voice):
http://imgur.com/a7hhtQ0
http://imgur.com/ZoNUkpG
Wally, on the other hand, was more loosely defined. Pretty much everything we 'know' about him came from his own mouth, and wasn't confirmed by any outside sources...
"Well, being one God and everything... I'm not just an independent entity. I'm sort of a combo of all different Gods, melded by the collective consciousness of humanity.":
http://imgur.com/QHoMHdd
(I could post several other scans in which he states that he is God, but that should suffice.)
States his name "Wally" is a variation of Yahweh:
http://imgur.com/EisG7tW
States he is omniscient:
http://imgur.com/ayZJrgH
But later states that his omniscience is limited to the past&present, and not the future:
http://imgur.com/MxUYj4Q
Heck, even Wally's bio says that he is a "self-proclaimed God":
http://imgur.com/gHKPsQU
So yeah, the dog/Presence ftw.
I remember letter pages from the series sort of implying that Wally wasn't God, although if anything, that bio should strengthen his case considering he basically wrote it himself (breaking the 4th wall), which is different from how the other bio entries are written.
Regardless, Peter David's Supergirl series (which is where Wally made his canon appearances) made it clear that the Presence was the ultimate power (I can post scans if needed).
And considering that the Dog is the Voice/The Presence....it's not that hard to determine a winner.
Originally posted by AsbestosFlaygon
I mean, the dog was the The Presence itself, NOT merely aspects of it, wasn't it?
Nope, apart from the scans already posted, another proof would be: the dog quite literally refers to the Spectre as "not of My wrath -- but of my desire for justice", in PS #5:
http://i.imgur.com/dLnOAef.jpg
And we all know that the Spectre is the wrath of God/Presence (who also created him)
