Originally posted by Nephthys
Malgus hasn't seen or met Revan. So how would he know that? Why should we think his opinion is accurate?
I don't think that Malgus was speculating, he would have known and assessed Revan's situation before making a judgment about him. Malgus wasn't stupid or speculator type guy, he was very smart, straight-forward and visionary.
Originally posted by Nephthys
As Ares says, Revan was probably a bit out of practice maybe. Though he had time to rest and heal up after he was rescued. He doesn't immediately run over to the Foundry and get killed.
Would it be possible to fully undo 3 centuries span of worth of damage within a span of few days?
Yes, Revan was exceptionally good with healing processes but I am not sure this would have been enough. It is almost a miracle that Revan sustained worst kind of torture for 3 centuries, most would have perished in his position IMO.
At minimum, Revan wasn't psychologically stable during SWTOR phase. And psychological stability plays a big part in effectiveness of an individual on the whole.