Rank the Star Trek Captains

On a Trek kick for now. Rank the Captains in the following areas:

-Intelligence

-Leadership

-Combat ability

Kirk/NU Kirk

Picard

Janeway

Sisko

Archer

Kirk
Picard
Sisko
Archer
Janeway

Janeway probably won't get any love at all.

LOL Janeway is a woman!

Picard > Kirk

Intelligence: Picard

Leadership: Picard

Combat Ability: Kirk

Originally posted by playa1258
Intelligence: Picard

Leadership: Picard

Combat Ability: Kirk

👆

Picard's highly intelligent, but Kirk's a genius.

Picard's strength is in diplomacy and leadership, he knows how to get the best out of people. He's a decent fighter as well.

Originally posted by Robtard
Picard's highly intelligent, but Kirk's a genius.

Picard's strength is in diplomacy and leadership, he knows how to get the best out of people. He's a decent fighter as well.

👆

Originally posted by Firefly218
Picard > Kirk

👆

Kirk being a genius is often forgot.

Really, Picard and Kirk rule. The rest can suck it.

Originally posted by playa1258
On a Trek kick for now. Rank the Captains in the following areas:

-Intelligence

-Leadership

-Combat ability

Kirk/NU Kirk

Picard

Janeway

Sisko

Archer

Haven't seen Enterprise so will not rank Archer.\

Intelligence
1.Picard
2.Sisko
3.Kirk
4.Janeway

Leadership
1.Sisko
2.Picard
3.Kirk
4.Janeway

Combat Ability
1.Kirk
2.Sisko
3.Picard
4.Janeway

Overall, I'd have to say the best was Sisko. Also had the best show.

Sisko ahead of Kirk ( a genius) in intelligence? Just curious.

I'm not so sure I buy that either. But I admit I haven't seen most of DS9 since the series launched.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Really, Picard and Kirk rule. The rest can suck it.

If those two had a child together, that kid would be a Q-Destroyer.

Amen.

Shatner Kirk.

/thread.

Favourite order.
Picard
Janeway
Kirk
Sisko
who dafuq is Archer?

Intelligence:
Picard and Sisko
Janeway
Kirk
Really who is Archer?

Leadership:
Picard
Sisko
Kirk
Janeway
I give up, no one give crap about Archer.

Combat:
I'm not sure, but I might give this to Sisko... he seems to kick a lot of Klingon, Cardissian and Hadarr ass.
The rest I'm not sure. Picard always has Data and Worf, Janeway is a woman, Kirk I guess is alright but he's always next to Spock which makes him look inferior, and Archer isn't even real to me.

Picard has an English accent.

/thread.