Yoda and Mace Windu Vs Palpatine(RotS)

Started by carthage3 pages
Originally posted by Based
"If so powerful you are, why leave?" Yeah Sidious is so badass here too.

So what? He still beat Yoda in the end. He made him run like a *****. He's beaten him in every encounter they've ever fought in, whether it was his dream sequence, the fight, etc. He is stronger and better than Yoda.

Disagree. If anything they tied in ROTS and the dream sequence Sidious only had the upper hand due to circumstance with Anakin being there.

Sidious was the one trying to leave, acting frustrated, and having the "Oh, shit!" look on his face throughout the fight. It's fair to assess that Yoda is a superior swordsmen due to either A.Palpatine was disarmed or B.He felt he couldn't best Yoda in a duel so he switched tactics to using the Force.

Palpatine may have stronger offensive Force powers but Yoda can hang. He's showed that he can counter his lightning with considerable effort.

Yoda and Palpatine as of ROTS are roughly equals with Palpatine perhaps having slightly more power in the Force and Yoda being a pretty reasonably superior swordsmen.

Adding Mace who is the second strongest Force-wielding Jedi and arguably the greatest duelist of the PT, who has already defeated Palpatine in lightsaber combat in his own right would guarantee death for Palpatine.

Originally posted by carthage
So what? He still beat Yoda in the end. He made him run like a *****. He's beaten him in every encounter they've ever fought in, whether it was his dream sequence, the fight, etc. He is stronger and better than Yoda.

*facepalm*

Originally posted by carthage
He didn't kill Yoda, because Yoda ran like a *****.

How was he supposed to win against Sidious and the Clones? He had to run.

Originally posted by Jaggarath
17:27:04 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : whats flashes
[17:27:08 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : kmc user and info
[17:27:52 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : yo
[17:28:24 29/03/14] @ Jack : here
[17:28:26 29/03/14] @ Jack : it is
[17:29:01 29/03/14] @ Jack : Username: DestroyeOfWind Password: 55619902
[17:30:12 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : nice HAHAHAHAHHA
[17:30:23 29/03/14] @ Jack : lol
[17:30:25 29/03/14] @ Jack : bwahahha
[17:31:34 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : dude
[17:31:36 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : ant is gona
[17:31:37 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : BEG WATCH
[17:31:51 29/03/14] @ Jack : yes LOL
[17:31:54 29/03/14] @ Jack : dont ever
[17:32:20 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : yo
[17:32:36 29/03/14] @ Jack : give him power lol
[17:33:15 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : agreed lol
[17:33:18 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : dude why the ****
[17:33:23 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : are emperor and flash on KMC?
[17:33:26 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : makes no sense
[17:33:39 29/03/14] @ Jack : flash made it in august last year dude
[17:33:44 29/03/14] @ Jack : emperor just made his account
[17:33:47 29/03/14] @ Jack : a fewdays ago
[17:33:56 29/03/14] @ Jack : ant told him to do so lol
[17:34:41 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : wtf
[17:34:44 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : flash needs
[17:34:49 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : to be more well KNOWN
[17:34:51 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : TO POST LINKS
[17:35:06 29/03/14] @ Jack : yes LOL
[17:35:08 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : we have
[17:35:11 29/03/14] @ Darthsith : markaragnos lol
[17:35:30 29/03/14] @ Jack : LMAO
[17:35:33 29/03/14] @ Jack : lets have two tho
[17:35:35 29/03/14] @ Jack : yo
[17:35:40 29/03/14] @ Jack : gtg man
[17:35:41 29/03/14] @ Jack : lets spam
[17:35:43 29/03/14] @ Jack : tomorrow tho
[17:35:48 29/03/14] @ Jack : a few hours before this time
[17:35:52 29/03/14] @ Jack : peace

SCREAMING

Team

Originally posted by carthage
So what? He still beat Yoda in the end. He made him run like a *****. He's beaten him in every encounter they've ever fought in, whether it was his dream sequence, the fight, etc. He is stronger and better than Yoda.
He was still cowardly and eventually barely got the better of him. He is Yodas equal in power. more cunning sure but not better with sabers either.

yoda was even noted in the script to disarm palpatine

imo yoda > palpatine in sabers since lucas

Originally posted by gold slorg
yoda was even noted in the script to disarm palpatine

imo yoda > palpatine in sabers since lucas

Yodais better with sabers I agree. Equal power I give Sidious the edge in cunning and he used that to gain the advantage on the **** up yoda. Even as a ghost yoda still would get erections just thinking about evolving through failure.

Didn't Gillard say that with tier 9's, it came down to environment, and that Yoda had the advantage there in the podium? Not sure if I recall correctly, though.

Gillard did say that about tier 9 fighters. I don't think he said anything about Yoda being in a position of advantage on the podium, although it's probably true.

Yeah, as I said, not entirely sure. Though it should be remembered that Sidious has fought two saber fights in a decade and nothing else, whereas Yoda presumably sparred often and fought actively in the clone wars. Sidious still retained his skill as a tier 9 duelist despite doing basically nothing to do with dueling for a decade.

Originally posted by Meatpants
Yeah, as I said, not entirely sure. Though it should be remembered that Sidious has fought two saber fights in a decade and nothing else, whereas Yoda presumably sparred often and fought actively in the clone wars. Sidious still retained his skill as a tier 9 duelist despite doing basically nothing to do with dueling for a decade.
Speculative nonsense.

It is like this post was written to trigger quan.

Either of the two solo 8-9/10 individually, together they stomp lmao.

Originally posted by Yellowfin
No, no, and no.

LMAO