Galactic Empire (ROTS) VS Rebel Alliance (ROTJ)
The galactic Empire just after the clone wars and order 66 Vs Rebel Alliance during return of the jedi, The rebellion leaders are Han,Leia, and Luke. The Galactic Empire leaders are ROTS Sidious,and Operation knightfall vader. Who would win? I think the empire would win since clones are vastly superior to undertrained, foolish, rebellion members. Thus 1 clone = 10 rebels and 1 clone commander or captain =20 Rebels.
They have this topic: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f86/t594731.html
Originally posted by Lord Lucienthey do have little to no training and no discipline they are basically just handed some blaster pistol and some crappy helmet that does nothing
The Rebels are untrained and foolish? Since when? Where are these totally arbitrary numbers coming from? Who even are you? What's wrong with your face?!
Originally posted by Q99they only took out 3... With leia killing one which the total kill count was 4. Most likely those rebels where the special forces since no average guard should be defending a ship that has the Death Star plans. There was only like 8 or 9 stormtroopers and there was like 20 rebels btw.
That's... just some ship guards, and they take out a good number of stormies.There's plenty of more elite ones like Page's Commandos, and nor do the rebels fight poorly at hoth.
Originally posted by PTforthewin
they only took out 3... With leia killing one which the total kill count was 4. Most likely those rebels where the special forces since no average guard should be defending a ship that has the Death Star plans. There was only like 8 or 9 stormtroopers and there was like 20 rebels btw.
Special forces aren't guards, those are two different roles to begin with. Also, we didn't *see* much of the fighting, and there was definitely more stormies than that (they were hooked up to a ISD, stormies can keep coming in til they won), and the stormies were Darth Vader's personal stormies so not average ones.
Also-also, Leia was going under cover, diverting elite forces to them would be suspicious. Being a senator was her defense, not military force. An elite defense would still lose but remove the diplomatic card.
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
We see like 10 guys get defeated after their tiny ship is immobilized and boarded, and suddenly we're fit to judge countless thousands of soldiers from across the entirety of the Alliance? Many of whom are Imperial defectors?That's like judging the entire Jedi Order based on Johun Othone.
Let's remember that before he was a Jedi, Kyle Katarn was... a rebel commando. Who worked with a fair number of other rebel commandos.
There've been multiple major projects taken down by rebel commandos.