Revan vs Dooku Sabers Battle

Started by DarthAnt663 pages

Ventress, Opress, and Kenobi are not amped!Malak's superior.
Skywalker and Yoda are though.

It'd help if we knew what Revan we're going with here. I mean is this KOTOR Revan, or Revan Reborn?

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Ventress, Opress, and Kenobi are not amped!Malak's superior.
Skywalker and Yoda are though.

Agreed.

Of course, Revan did kick amped!Malak's ass a half dozen times in a row after fighting through an army.

Nah, he kicked his ass 9 times, not 6. 😉

Theres not really a way to prove that.

There were 8 stasis pods, not 6. :/

Originally posted by UltimateAnomaly
It speaks for itself, honestly. Through the Clone Wars he's fought rather hardcore opponents, who are beyond the level of someone like Malak.

Where not talking about one component. What components are so superior that he fought to an amp Malak? I can only think of one.

Originally posted by UltimateAnomaly
Don't get me wrong, I think Revan is awesome and he's one of my favorite characters, I just don't see him outright winning the majority of his fights with Dooku.

That is fine I accept that he won’t.

Originally posted by UltimateAnomaly
Who has more saber-to-saber experience than Revan where it counts.

Even if the components are superior in skill, how does that equate to more saber to saber experience?

I mean theres no way to prove Revan didn't kill a few of the Jedi before Malak drained them.

Originally posted by UltimateAnomaly
It'd help if we knew what Revan we're going with here. I mean is this KOTOR Revan, or Revan Reborn?

Whatever their primes are to you.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I mean theres no way to prove Revan didn't kill a few of the Jedi before Malak drained them.

Ah, true. However no canonical sources say he did, and all say Malak drained the Jedi. So even if he did, Malak would have still replenished himself a lot.

I'm going with Dooku here.

Originally posted by carthage
Dooku SLAUGHTERHOUSE

👆 For once I agree.

Ha. Like he "slaughterhoused" Kenobi or Savage... 👆

Spoiler:
Oh wait, he didn't.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Ha. Like he "slaughterhoused" Kenobi or Savage... 👆
Spoiler:
Oh wait, he didn't.

What? Are you serious? He nearly killed Kenobi with Anakin as support on the Pyke planet.

And Kenobi-level swordsmanship is as much as I'd be willing to give Revan with his feats, and that's being very generous.

Exactly, but he didn't. He didn't even kill Kenobi, let alone slaughter him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7h_wnWlk518
And for what its worth, Kenobi beats Dooku via cutscene in that new Clone Wars game. 😉

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Exactly, but he didn't. He didn't even kill Kenobi, let alone slaughter him.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7h_wnWlk518
And for what its worth, Kenobi beats Dooku via cutscene in that new Clone Wars game. 😉

This is directly contradicted by the T-canon source which does not mention Dooku's attack on Kenobi, nor does it show any visible damage to his command ship.

Further contradicted by Dooku being at the Separatist Fleet Rendezvous point. 😉

Does it contradict it? Wookieepedia describes it as "The duel between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Count Dooku based during the episode Shadow of Malevolence. In the level, while Anakin Skywalker and his forces fight the Malevolence, Dooku attacks Obi-Wan's ship and attacks Kenobi. After a long duel, Obi-Wan defeats Dooku, but is forced to leave the clone troopers to watch Dooku as he goes with Anakin to fight the Malevolence. Dooku kills the clones and escapes."

Based off this, it doesn't contradict anything. Dooku could have then escaped back to the Separatist Fleet Rendezvous. Regardless, my point stands Kenobi has never been slaughtered by Dooku.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Does it contradict it? Wookieepedia describes it as "The duel between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Count Dooku based during the episode Shadow of Malevolence. In the level, while Anakin Skywalker and his forces fight the Malevolence, Dooku attacks Obi-Wan's ship and attacks Kenobi. After a long duel, Obi-Wan defeats Dooku, but is forced to leave the clone troopers to watch Dooku as he goes with Anakin to fight the Malevolence. Dooku kills the clones and escapes."

Based off this, it doesn't contradict anything. Dooku could have then escaped back to the Separatist Fleet Rendezvous. Regardless, my point stands Kenobi has never been slaughtered by Dooku.

No he can't. When Malevolence is hit Dooku contacts Grievous about sending him Padme. He'd literally have to be in two places at once.

Padme is not even in "Shadow of Malevolence." :/
You are referring to "Destroy Malevolence."

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Ventress, Opress, and Kenobi are not amped!Malak's superior.
Skywalker and Yoda are though.

Not that this matters, since Revan used the Force during their duel. I doubt even Revan is better than Malak in pure sabers.