Windu,Yoda,and Luke VS Vitiate,Sidious,Plagueis

Most powerful jedis VS most powerful siths
All are at there primes

Nice.

Windu takes Plagueis

Yoda takes Vitiate

Luke takes Sidious

Jedi win.

Also, I would put Jacen and HoT over Mace.

Plagueis kills Windu

Yoda kills Vitiate

and Luke finishes Sidious while the two Jedi converge and kill Plagueis

Vitiate is the weak link, he isn't helping the sith unless he knows wicked battle meditation.

How does Windu lose to Plagueis? Being equivalent to TPM palpatine isn't going to help against the Jedi who defeated his more powerful incarnation. Plus, Vaapad give him another edge in sabers.

Better speed, physical attributes, likely comparable saber skill. And given Plagueis's disdain for lightsaber combat, Vaapad would likely not help Windu.

Mace scared a battle droid in S1

Originally posted by carthage
Better speed, physical attributes, likely comparable saber skill. And given Plagueis's disdain for lightsaber combat, Vaapad would likely not help Windu.

Windu mastered all 7 forms and defeated ROTS Sidious (although the novel implies Palpatine feigned his defeat.). His speed equaled Sidious' and even Anakin stated they were nothing more than red and purple blurs. Even if Plagueis disdains lightsaber combat and decides to use the Force, Mace can still win.

The movie showed Palpatine trying but failing, the movie is more canon then the book, so palpatine was trying.

Some people feel that Palpatine was feigning, so I added it, but that wasn't to detract from the rest of my post. It was just an aside.

The part where palpatine was begging for mercy the "please don't kill me" "I'm to weak" was probably just bad acting and writing

Originally posted by PTforthewin
The part where palpatine was begging for mercy the "please don't kill me" "I'm to weak" was probably just bad acting and writing

He was lying. As soon as Windu got his hand cut off, Palpatine hit him with a huge burst of lightning, while taunting him.

He still was trying during the saber fight

I agree, the novel just shows it differently. As this is the EU forum, I thought I'd add it for the people who believe it.