HMS Endeavour vs. Black Pearl and Flying Dutchman

Started by Lonious1 pages
Lonious Junior Member

HMS Endeavour vs. Black Pearl and Flying Dutchman

Same scenario as PotC: AWE. The two pirate ships surround the larger Man-o-War and they fire broadsides.

However, this time, Cutler Beckett opens fire.

Who wins?

COG Veteran Teh GrOovY 1

Endeavor gets turned to splinters.

Lonious Junior Member
Originally posted by COG Veteran
Endeavor gets turned to splinters.

I actually believe the opposite to be true. If you do a little research you will find out that a fully fledged warship like the Endeavor outguns the entire armament of both pirates by a wide margin. Plus the fact that they flanked her, which is technically a very bad idea, giving her the opportunity to fire a massive 98 gun double broadside.

In real life they probably would've been turned into matchsticks.

juggerman Senior Member

The Dutchman is a damn magical ship. It was pretty much destroyed and sunk but rose a few minutes later. Endeavour gets got son.

ares834 Senior Member
Originally posted by COG Veteran
Endeavor gets turned to splinters.
DTM Senior Member

What movie is the Endeavour from?

KingD19 Shai-Gen's Enigmatic Wong

Pirates of the Caribbean.

Time Immemorial Restricted

The endeavor is doomed against those two ships.

Lonious Junior Member
Originally posted by Time Immemorial
The endeavor is doomed against those two ships.

Supernatural as they are, I still don't get how they are actually invincible against physical damage. Why then did they fight each other? All we know is that the Dutchman can resurface if it sinks. Still doesn't prevent the Endeavour from possibly eviscerating its hull with a 48 gun broadside.

Look and be scared.

Utrigita Senior Member
Originally posted by COG Veteran
Endeavor gets turned to splinters.
DTM Senior Member

Didnt the Flying Dutchman kill the Kraken (against Jones' will, but he was ordered to do it, so he obeyed), if so, unless you think the Endeavour is beating the Kraken, then BP and FD take this solidly. Again, it being a magically unsinkable ship is a huge thing to get around.

COG Veteran Teh GrOovY 1

Originally posted by Lonious
I actually believe the opposite to be true. If you do a little research you will find out that a fully fledged warship like the Endeavor outguns the entire armament of both pirates by a wide margin. Plus the fact that they flanked her, which is technically a very bad idea, giving her the opportunity to fire a massive 98 gun double broadside.

In real life they probably would've been turned into matchsticks.


Both the Pearl and FD were capable of taking down armadas. Even tho the endeavor is an impressively sized ship, that's all it is. Endeavor < armada < pearl and FD.

The_Tempest Senior Member
Originally posted by COG Veteran
Endeavor gets turned to splinters but solely due to the presence of the Dutchman. The Pearl alone is no match for the Endeavor, which is why Gibbs and co. were shitting bricks and Beckett was all smugface til the Dutchman resurfaced.