Asgaurdians vs Hulk

Originally posted by Impediment
With CIS and PIS off......Thor dominates.

Does PIS and CIS not mean, Plot induced stupidity and Character induced stupidity?

I was trying to make it a fair fight.

Originally posted by Impediment
With CIS and PIS off......Thor dominates.

He doesn't seem to understand that Thor can fly and has ranged attacks. or what removing PIS/CIS actually means.

Originally posted by Silent Master
He doesn't seem to understand that Thor can fly and has ranged attacks. or what removing PIS/CIS actually means.

Plot induced stupidity and Character induced stupidity right?

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Plot induced stupidity and Character induced stupidity right?

Yes, but do you understand what turning those off actually means as it pertains to a fight?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yes, but do you understand what turning those off actually means as it pertains to a fight?

I thought it meant things like, Loki would not just stand there and get face smashed while trying to talk to the Hulk. Or like having a Jet Fighter come in an draw Hulk off Thor while they in a brawl. Stupid character/story stuff.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
I thought it meant things like, Loki would not just stand there and get face smashed while trying to talk to the Hulk. Or like having a Jet Fighter come in an draw Hulk off Thor while they in a brawl. Stupid character/story stuff.

Like say trying to fight with Hulk in HTH when you have flight and ranged attacks?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Like say trying to fight with Hulk in HTH when you have flight and ranged attacks?

Well I didn't understand turning those off meant he would go straight to flight. Anyways Hulk loses then.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Well I didn't understand turning those off meant he would go straight to flight. Anyways Hulk loses then.

Why would Thor choose to fight the Hulk in HTH when he has flight and ranged attacks?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why would Thor choose to fight the Hulk in HTH when he has flight and ranged attacks?

He seems like a brawler to me. Likes to fight with his hands and hammer.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
He seems like a brawler to me. Likes to fight with his hands and hammer.

Yea..if you ignore all the times he uses his other powers in the movies.

Which was in the minority to the times he used his hammer to just bash someone.

Originally posted by DTM
Which was in the minority to the times he used his hammer to just bash someone.

Actually he used powers and/or ranged attacks in most of his fights during the movies.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea..if you ignore all the times he uses his other powers in the movies.

Lets add up the times he used his ranged attack vs hand to hand. I am certain he way more h2h showings.

The ranged times I can remember are him vs Iron Man, and him vs the Worm Hole in Avengers.

What other times are there? Every other time, it was Hand to Hand IIRC.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Actually he used powers and/or ranged attacks in most of his fights during the movies.

Thor has been in 3 movies now, fighting many fights all throughout, and you think his main form of offense overall was lightning, and not pummeling foes with his hammer? Seriously?? I think Im watching different movies than you then.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Lets add up the times he used his ranged attack vs hand to hand. I am certain he way more h2h showings.

The ranged times I can remember are him vs Iron Man, and him vs the Worm Hole in Avengers.

What other times are there? Every other time, it was Hand to Hand IIRC.

By all means list all the fights where he uses no powers or ranged attacks and I'll list the ones where he does.

Originally posted by DTM
Thor has been in 3 movies now, fighting many fights all throughout, and you think his main form of offense overall was lightning, and not pummeling foes with his hammer? Seriously?? I think Im watching different movies than you then.

I was thinking the same thing🙂

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
I was thinking the same thing🙂

Does this mean you accept the challenge of comparing fights where he only uses HTH to the ones where he uses powers/ranged attacks?

Im shocked you even think its close, to me Thor attacked with Hammer Smashing way more than he did throwing around lightning (but not, sorry, Im not about to sit through 3 movies again just to get exact comparisons).

Originally posted by Silent Master
Does this mean you accept the challenge of caring fights where he only uses HTH to the ones where he uses powers/ranged attacks?

His main offense was melee with his hammer.

Thor

Frost giants- Hammer &Long hand to hand battle followed by a power attack

Frost Giant Monster-Flying with Hammer

Destroyer-Same attack as above

Loki-Hammer Attack

Thor 2

Giant Rock Monster-Hammer attack

Prison scene-Hammer attack

Brief Malekith and Kurse in Asgaurd- Lighting and Hammer throw

Main Kurse fight-H2H- Hammer was tossed aside

Malekith-Mainly all Hammer throws with one ground based lighting attack

Avengers

Ironman fight-Lighting then all H2H with hammer

Hulk fight-H2H with Hammer

Chitari battle- One big lighting attack, rest H2H with hammer.

So thats 3 ranged lighting attacks in 3 movies?

Remember that each and every hammer strike should be counted, so if he throws lightning once and then hammers 10 times afterwards for the fight, its Lightning - 1, Pummeling - 10.