Archilles/Maximus vs Captain America

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
He struggled with Batroc and Achilles would put Batroc in the dirt, its not as clear as you make it. The giant Achilles fought was 3 times his size and strength and Achilles put him in the dirt. Strength has nothing to do with a sword and shield fight. To add cap lacks the sword and usually tosses his shield at the first sign of trouble.

Now who's lowballing? Once Cap got serious he put Batroc down in moments.

And Achilles didn't even really fight the champion. He took advantage of his speed, got a critical hit, and he died. He didn't even move.

Strength has a lot to do with a sword and shield fight, especially when the strongest guy is also highly skilled and fast as hell.

And we all know Cap would never toss his shield if he was going up against 2 guys with swords.

Originally posted by KingD19
Now who's lowballing? Once Cap got serious he put Batroc down in moments.

And Achilles didn't even really fight the champion. He took advantage of his speed, got a critical hit, and he died. He didn't even move.

Strength has a lot to do with a sword and shield fight, especially when the strongest guy is also highly skilled and fast as hell.

And we all know Cap would never toss his shield if he was going up against 2 guys with swords.

Very true.

Originally posted by KingD19
Now who's lowballing? Once Cap got serious he put Batroc down in moments.

And Achilles didn't even really fight the champion. He took advantage of his speed, got a critical hit, and he died. He didn't even move.

Strength has a lot to do with a sword and shield fight, especially when the strongest guy is also highly skilled and fast as hell.

And we all know Cap would never toss his shield if he was going up against 2 guys with swords.

Nah not really a low ball to say he had trouble with someone extremely fast and talented. I actually have a basis for an opinion because of the Batroc fight..

Cap doesn't have a sword so your second point is invalid.

Cap tosses his shield at guys with ranged weapons, why would he not toss it at people with swords?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Very true.

Says the guy who worships Batroc.

Cap would beat Achilles and Maximus, but they would make him work for it.

Originally posted by KingD19
Maximus lasts a few seconds max. Them both having blades means Cap will be taking this seriously. Maximus gets booted away, and Achilles puts up a brief fight before Cap's combo of higher strength, comparable skill, and higher speed overwhelm him.

The two of them skewer Cap.

Maximus is slow and weak. He'd be knocked out in one hit.

And in the time it takes Cap to KO him, he leaves himself open for an Achilles attack. Achilles takes his head off.

I swear, there is so much Avengers wanking here it's sickening. IM, Thor, Hulk, Cap, everyone seems to love polishing their knobs.

No.

Cap handles the duo with mild-difficulty

I see, just cuz, right? So as Cap blocks one attack, how does he block the second coming from a completely different angle?

Originally posted by RJ 2.0
I see, just cuz, right? So as Cap blocks one attack, how does he block the second coming from a completely different angle?

😆 +1

Originally posted by RJ 2.0
I see, just cuz, right? So as Cap blocks one attack, how does he block the second coming from a completely different angle?

Originally posted by RJ 2.0
I see, just cuz, right? So as Cap blocks one attack, how does he block the second coming from a completely different angle?

So yes. Cap wins because. Deal with it.

Lol...the debates in this thread. Ach took out a group of trained me easily. Everything he did was easy and again, this was against trained warriors. Cap isn't beating any of these two easily and arguments can be made on them winning. Achilles holds the speed advantage...the guy was simply untouchable against the best warriors. His accuracy was uncanny. Didn't know Cap got wanked so hard.

Cap is superior in almost every category, he shouldn't have much trouble here.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...the debates in this thread. Ach took out a group of trained me easily. Everything he did was easy and again, this was against trained warriors. Cap isn't beating any of these two easily and arguments can be made on them winning. Achilles holds the speed advantage...the guy was simply untouchable against the best warriors. His accuracy was uncanny. Didn't know Cap got wanked so hard.

Cap would easily replicate Achille's feat. Achilles is good, and he is one of my personal favorites, but he is no Captain America.

By the way those best warriors are nothing compared to the people Cap has faced.

Again SMH.

Also Maximus is completely irrelevant in this matchup. He gets thrown, punched or kicked 10 feet away from cap.

Edit I could go on and say that you are riding Achielles's dick in the same fashion Hulk is riding Superman's, but I'm not going there....

131 313

America, **** yeah.

YouTube video

Maximus is pathetic compared to either of the other two. And Achilles has done absolutely nothing that puts him on Cap's level. Take away his shield and tie his hands behind his back or something, then maybe.

Unless one of the warriors gets a deep throat wound on Cap, Cap's not going down easily, as he can take alien energy blast, bullets, stabbings and massive concussions and still keep fighting at close to full potential.

IMO, they based Captain America off McClane.

And Maximus is my favorite between Achilles, Leonidas and him. =\