Malak vs Traya vs Maul

Hmm? Any evidence for that?

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Hmm? Any evidence for that?

You are not asking about the Revan part are you?

I am. what evidence is their that "only Revan," could take down Malak? Base Malak, at that. And that can have just as much to do with circumstance as power.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I am. what evidence is their that "only Revan," could take down Malak? Base Malak, at that. And that can have just as much to do with circumstance as power.

I do not have a quote if there is one. It is an assumption based upon the fact that the Jedi believe Revan to be the only hope and Traya existed while Malak was dark lord and never tried to dethrone him even though she wanted revenge only on the Jedi at this time.

Kotor3 is right. It was said on numerous occasions Revan was the Order's only hope.
Then again, they weren't including Traya anyway.

Well yeah, circumstance. Why in the hell would the jedi ever trust Traya? And yeah, I'm not sure why she'd attempt to dethrone him, why do that when the jedi already will?

I don't think Traya was still a Jedi.
She was corrupted by Malachor shortly after Revan's fall.

Traya had no reason to oppose Malak or any desire to rule.

Also my timeline is unsure but wasn't she training Nihilus at this point? Or maybe she'd already been betrayed?

Malak lost to Revan. I think he is not given enough credit. I do not see Traya giving Revan the same amount of trouble as Malak, personally.

I do, if Traya has access to the powers of the star forge, has a bunch of bodies to drain energy from, and is fighting a Revan who'd just battled through the entire Star Forge.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Traya had no reason to oppose Malak or any desire to rule.

Also my timeline is unsure but wasn't she training Nihilus at this point? Or maybe she'd already been betrayed?

No I believe that wasn't until the Civil War ended.

It is all assumptions what her reasons may have been since she was created at time of Kotor 1. She definitely hated the Jedi for exiling her.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I do, if Traya has access to the powers of the star forge, has a bunch of bodies to drain energy from, and is fighting a Revan who'd just battled through the entire Star Forge.

Makes sense.

It could go either way between them two. I honestly do not see Maul beating either of them.

👆

thanks for being open. Unlike.....some people.

Originally posted by Kotor3
Malak lost to Revan. I think he is not given enough credit.

True, he should definitely be given more credit for that. Not many people could.... lose to Revan.

Originally posted by Kotor3
No I believe that wasn't until the Civil War ended.

It is all assumptions what her reasons may have been since she was created at time of Kotor 1. She definitely hated the Jedi for exiling her.

She didn't want to kill them though. Well, not until proving them wrong.

See now we understand each other.

Yes we do. 👆

Originally posted by Nephthys
Even without the drain I'd say Traya wins.

Inclined to agree, though Maul and Traya are a strange matchup to envision.