Ninja assassin vs Hogwarts

Started by RJ 2.05 pages

Originally posted by Silent Master
Just like the basilisk and the troll used wizard magic to avoid being seen?
The troll? Think on that, who allowed the troll access to the castle?

The basilisk has already been explained.

So now your argument is that the Quirrell put a spell on the troll, the basilisk never went anywhere near a ghost or painting and that the ghosts and paintings ignored Sirius in dog form.

Where was any of this stated in the movies?

No. Quirrell ALLOWED the troll access to the castle because he was being controlled by Voldy.

The Basilisk was under Voldemort's protection.

I swear, it's like you people have never seen a HP movie.

How does Quirrell letting the troll in and the basilisk being controlled stop the ghosts and paintings from alerting someone?

Obviously Quirrell alerted them before the paintings/ghosts could.

Do the paintings/ghost have special vision powers? I don't recall that they do, ergo the ninja ability at stealth-infiltration > them.

No. They have eyes. And what they'll see against the ninja is nothing. Because they're ninjas.

Exactly.

Proof: There's a total of 187 Ninja in the picture below.

188 if you count the rookie you can juuuust make out behind that pipe in the corner.

He's in Day 1 of training and hasn't earned the title of "Ninja" yet.

Oh yeah. They're so secretive with their training methods. I forgot he was called a shadow blob until he's made his first kill from the inky darkness of the shadows. From the recesses of a man's mind..

Originally posted by Robtard
Do the paintings/ghost have special vision powers? I don't recall that they do, ergo the ninja ability at stealth-infiltration > them.

He's pulling a quan, IE stating a laughable opinion and then ignoring all evidence that says otherwise; I mean you saw the excuses he made for the paintings and ghosts not reporting the Troll, Basilisk or Sirius. Yet somehow they'll be able to spot the ninjas and report them instantly.

This is of course after the ninjas don't make it into the castle because OP forgot to specify that they can get through the shield.

The shield at the end of DH2 isn't in effect, since the wizards aren't aware they're about to be attacked.

Besides, Ninja are magical creatures, they could just get through anyways.

Originally posted by Robtard
Do the paintings/ghost have special vision powers? I don't recall that they do, ergo the ninja ability at stealth-infiltration > them.
I am assuming that Potter is in the castle? The Weasley's?

Harry for sure is in the castle; probably in a closet.

Marauder's map. And Snape.

/thread.

Why would anyone be looking at the map?

Lol, so the wizards are just sitting there, blindfolded and hog tied?

Man, you really hate Potter.

One thing: The OP is completely BS, there is no ninja magic that would allow Ninja to see Hogwarts in the first place.

The wizards don't know an attack is coming, so they'd be going about their daily routine.