Thanos vs. Hulk

Originally posted by carver9
He is smiling AND calm when the mountain fell on him and he had to catch the mountain (while again, in a calm state). He wasn't even mad when the mountain was on him which is the reason Spiderman started insulting him to make him angry. By the way, reported. A fight doesn't indicate how strong a character is. Gamora is a class 10 and has good showings against Thanos. Spiderman, hell, Batman himself lasted against a Superman that was trying to kill him. Thing is thing, he does well for a little and gets two pieced. I asked you to provide evidence, not what you thought. That was Professor Hulk by the way, a Hulk that is much weaker than Savage. While I'm reporting you, what fts do you have that backs up your claims?

Did you read my post in its entirety, especially the part about ARTISTIC LICENSE?
Hulk wasn't holding the mountain when he was smiling. The mountain was stuck already. Hulk just put his arms up in an attempt to brace the mountain.

A fight CAN indicate how strong a character is when we see them striking another character. Hulk has struck Colossus, Thing, etc. and also has been hit by them. Thing maxes out at 100 tons. Hulk was operating at several times those characters when he fought them at times.

Batman lasting against Superman trying to kill him PROVES that Superman was operating at very low strength levels. Gamora is beyond class 10 but again she was never hit by Thanos to show Thanos strength. Thanos durability in that scene was written low because Gamora was able to harm him.

In other words, characters are written down to fight other characters. Their durability, strength, etc. can be reduced greatly in order to fit the plot.

I provided evidence. Hulk fights with Thing, Colossus, etc. shows his strength level. Unless you think a 100 ton being can survive a hit against a million ton punch or more? Do you know who Merged Hulk is? Geez, it's Professor Hulk. Why didn't you know this? I stated that in my post. I'm talking about Savage Hulk and you post something with Merged Hulk. Hilarious.

LMAO. I'll give you something to report. You are an idiot.

I gave you plenty of evidence.
1. Hulk's many many fights with lower beings, etc.
2. Hulk's jumping 3 miles proves he is using thousands of tons of force.

I never claimed what level Hulk will be on a forum fight. I was addressing a totally different issue (until you butted in) explaining Hulk's Range in comics (from his lowest to his highest). You instantly took it to me that I was arguing that Hulk starts out with a few hundred tons or that's his average. I never said nor implied that. As far as I'm concerned, Savage Hulk starts with at least millions of tons of strength IN A FORUM FIGHT.

Originally posted by h1a8
Did you read my post in its entirety, especially the part about ARTISTIC LICENSE?
Hulk wasn't holding the mountain when he was smiling. The mountain was stuck already. Hulk just put his arms up in an attempt to brace the mountain.

A fight CAN indicate how strong a character is when we see them striking another character. Hulk has struck Colossus, Thing, etc. and also has been hit by them. Thing maxes out at 100 tons. Hulk was operating at several times those characters when he fought them at times.

Batman lasting against Superman trying to kill him PROVES that Superman was operating at very low strength levels. Gamora is beyond class 10 but again she was never hit by Thanos to show Thanos strength. Thanos durability in that scene was written low because Gamora was able to harm him.

In other words, characters are written down to fight other characters. Their durability, strength, etc. can be reduced greatly in order to fit the plot.

I provided evidence. Hulk fights with Thing, Colossus, etc. shows his strength level. Unless you think a 100 ton being can survive a hit against a million ton punch or more? Do you know who Merged Hulk is? Geez, it's Professor Hulk. Why didn't you know this? I stated that in my post. I'm talking about Savage Hulk and you post something with Merged Hulk. Hilarious.

LMAO. I'll give you something to report. You are an idiot.

I gave you plenty of evidence.
1. Hulk's many many fights with lower beings, etc.
2. Hulk's jumping 3 miles proves he is using thousands of tons of force.

I never claimed what level Hulk will be on a forum fight. I was addressing a totally different issue (until you butted in) explaining Hulk's Range in comics (from his lowest to his highest). You instantly took it to me that I was arguing that Hulk starts out with a few hundred tons or that's his average. I never said nor implied that. As far as I'm concerned, Savage Hulk starts with at least millions of tons of strength IN A FORUM FIGHT.

Prove that he was angry or be quiet. The last we see of him before he caught the mountain, he was smiling. Even when the mountain was on him he wasn't showing a sign of anger (which drives his power). Now again, PROVE IT.

When Hulk fought Colossus, he was weakened. Which is the reason he was commenting on how tired he was and Colossus even bringing up Hulk looking weak.

What fights of Thing vs Hulk makes you think Thing can hang with him let alone take him down to the levels you are bringing him. Have you read ANYTHING on Thing? He doesn't max out at 100 ton. He has fts above that. Reported again.

Lol...Hulk doesn't always have to leap out of orbit just to prove his strength. Also, when has Hulk jumped 3 miles? What if I post Doomsday jumping only around the corner from where he was at, does that give us an indication on how strong he is?

What many many fights does Hulk have against lower being to make you think he doesn't operate at high Herald level strengths? Provide scans. I don't care about what you THINK or what's in your head. I want evidence.

Show me where he starts at in a comic less than a million. Show me where you even get the millions of tons from when we see a calm Hulk supporting a mountain twice the size of our biggest mountain.

Also, Hulk holds back just like any other hero does. It's what he does which has been explained on numerous of occasions. Hulk isn't out to kill Thing or whoever else he is fighting. His goal is to be left alone. So I need more proof that he is trying to kill Thing when he strike him. Provide a scan because on panel it has bee stated more than once that Hulk hold back his power in prevention of killing anyone. Don't reply to this post unless you have evidence. I don't care about your calculations.

I think carver prime is being unleashed. He's just opened his sixth carver gate....once all the gates are opened, the Carvatar state is reached.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I think carver prime is being unleashed. He's just opened his sixth carver gate....once all the gates are opened, the Carvatar state is reached.

😂

Naah, H1 just gets to me. I give you mad props daily on going back and forth with him. Don't know how you do it.

Lol @ Carvatar state

Originally posted by h1a8
No offense but you are ignorant to reality. Hulk and Thor only operate in the billions of tons in their high end showings. Hulk and Thor has fought many beings whose strength level is very close to 100 tons. Hulk and Thor has hit and threw things around that estimates that they are operating between a few thousand tons to tens of thousands of tons.
Hulk, in his average showings, jumps 3 miles per leap when traveling. This my friend is a few thousand tons of force Hulk is using with his legs. And legs are stronger than arms.

Hulk jumping 3 miles is just that... Hulk jumping 3miles. We know he's capable of jumping a lot further because he's done it probably 100's of times.

Guys, get back to topic. On panel feats>>>>whatever you think.

So Carver is still dodging Quan?

Originally posted by carver9
Prove that he was angry or be quiet. The last we see of him before he caught the mountain, he was smiling. Even when the mountain was on him he wasn't showing a sign of anger (which drives his power). Now again, PROVE IT.

When Hulk fought Colossus, he was weakened. Which is the reason he was commenting on how tired he was and Colossus even bringing up Hulk looking weak.

What fights of Thing vs Hulk makes you think Thing can hang with him let alone take him down to the levels you are bringing him. Have you read ANYTHING on Thing? He doesn't max out at 100 ton. He has fts above that. Reported again.

Lol...Hulk doesn't always have to leap out of orbit just to prove his strength. Also, when has Hulk jumped 3 miles? What if I post Doomsday jumping only around the corner from where he was at, does that give us an indication on how strong he is?

What many many fights does Hulk have against lower being to make you think he doesn't operate at high Herald level strengths? Provide scans. I don't care about what you THINK or what's in your head. I want evidence.

Show me where he starts at in a comic less than a million. Show me where you even get the millions of tons from when we see a calm Hulk supporting a mountain twice the size of our biggest mountain.

Also, Hulk holds back just like any other hero does. It's what he does which has been explained on numerous of occasions. Hulk isn't out to kill Thing or whoever else he is fighting. His goal is to be left alone. So I need more proof that he is trying to kill Thing when he strike him. Provide a scan because on panel it has bee stated more than once that Hulk hold back his power in prevention of killing anyone. Don't reply to this post unless you have evidence. I don't care about your calculations.

From this point you are trolling. You insist on arguing Merged Hulk when I stated Savage Hulk. Colossus fought Hulk several times. WWH even comments on their fights in WWH.

I never claimed Thing could take Hulk down. Thing is around 100 tons. Hulk at his lowest showings ever is a few hundred tons. That means Thing fought and lasted with Hulk enough to show that Hulk was at most a few times stronger than Thing. Thing took hits and gave Hulk some good hits. If Hulk was operating at millions of tons or more then Thing and Colossus would be phucking dead or koed in one shot.

What feats have Thing above 100 tons? Prove it. He is actually one of the rare characters whose strength has actually been measured in a comic book (several times). If Thing does have any feats above 100 tons then it isn't much above it.

Hulk for a high majority of his showings jumps around 3 miles. It ranges from 1-4 miles to be more precise. That's average Hulk. Everyone knows this. This is common comic book knowledge. You of all people should know that. Why argue for a character you know nothing about?

Hulk holds back is a retcon. So I'll accept that. But When the writer's wrote his fights with Sasquach, Wendigo, Thing, Colossus, etc. they were not thinking Hulk is holding back. But this is irrelevant since I said Hulk has OPERATED (that implies the possibility of him holding back).

With that said, WWH and higher wins. Any lower Hulk is weaker than Thanos.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
😂
Come on H1 you can't believe that surely. Hulk and Thor have fought Captain America does that mean they are only operating at 1 to 5 tons in those scenes too? Your logic is terrible. Fighting someone weaker than themselves doesn't mean they are equal in strength or on the same level, that shouldn't even need to be said, and durability =/= strength. Sometimes their opponent may be tougher than they are strong, then there's the fact Hulk and Thor hold back tremendously against humans or weaker opponents.

Hulk jumping 3 miles is just that... Hulk jumping 3miles. We know he's capable of jumping a lot further because he's done it probably 100's of times.

I'm not claiming Hulk's strength. I'm claiming the strength he has operated at. Whether it was because he was holding back or bad writing, it doesn't matter.
My point was that the OP should specify which Hulk is being pitted against Thanos since Hulk's strength fluctuates wildly.
I don't see the purpose of arguing strength of a character who doesn't have a fixed strength. Hulk can be stronger AND weaker than Thanos depending on the circumstance.
End of Thread.

Hulk is much stronger than Thanos.

Originally posted by Xplosive
Hulk is much stronger than Thanos.

Thanos

Originally posted by Xplosive
Hulk is much stronger than Thanos.

Originally posted by Werewolf582
Thanos

Hulk starts off at high Herald strength until proven otherwise by a respectable poster.

Originally posted by Xplosive
Hulk is much stronger than Thanos.

Based on whatt? You dont see Hulk beating high heralds down with his fists nearly as much or as badly as Thanos.

What High Heralds did Thanos beat down with his fist? I remember him 7 punching Surfer and killing him. I consider Thor damage soak above Surfers and this is what 3 punches did to Thor.

http://s226.photobucket.com/user/HulkFights/media/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/2.jpg.html
http://s226.photobucket.com/user/HulkFights/media/Vs%20Thor/Fight%205/3.jpg.html

What other comparable fights do we have? Captain Marvell was one shot koed by a pimp slap from the Hulk. Hell, Hulk clapped his hands together and dropped him and Hulk speed was uncanny to CM whereas he was blitzing Thanos left and right. Can't remember if Thanos fought Jack of Hearts but Hulk mud stomped him as well. There really isn't many Herald fights we can compare them too but they both share the idea of dropping Heralds. Hulk's team battles looks better though. The guy has literally fought every team on the planet.

Originally posted by JayDaDon
Based on whatt? You dont see Hulk beating high heralds down with his fists nearly as much or as badly as Thanos.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk starts off at high Herald strength until proven otherwise by a respectable poster.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
If he was a villain that appeared once every few years and had a writer who couldn't ever bear to see his pet lose, best believe Hulk would treat top tiers exactly the same. Thanos has never really done anything amazing strength wise anyway.

His physical manhandling of the high herald tier is impressive enough. He doesnt really need any uber lifting feats not to mention even is he wasnt quite as strong, his durability is so high it doesnt matter much.