Patient_Leech
Perfect Organism
Christopher Nolan thinks that the Haters Need to Watch The Movie Again.
Well, Mr. Nolan, if you hadn't filmed it so shittily and made it 3 hours long, then perhaps I would consider that, but since it's more of a concept for a book and not a film (a very visual medium mind you), then maybe you should just release a novelization of it. The story and concepts would no doubt play out much better in book form.
Originally posted by Lestov16
Wow. Only got a 74% on RT (Inception got 86%). I was expecting this film to be far, far better, especially since this was originally a Spielberg film. I'll still give it a shot.
74% (or 73%, what it's at now) is WAAAYY too high. That's extremely generous and deceptive quite frankly. When so few of the elements of the film work, that is a ridiculously high score. I tend to agree with jaden in giving it about a 5/10. I'd say it's closer to about 50% success.
Originally posted by jaden101
About the closest comparison you can make is the film 'Contact' but that was more successful in marrying a coherent plot, realistic science and emotional resonance than Interstellar is.
Contact is a MUCH better film. One of my favorite books, too, btw.
Originally posted by dadudemon
I've already seen John Wick.
See it again. I wish I had, haha.. especially since Interstellar was sort of a birthday gift movie for me.
Originally posted by Quincy
The movie starts with something so bizarre and out of place that the "twist" at the end is telegraphed 3 hours in advance, and the rest of the movie you just wait for the "reveal."
I don't really fault it for that. That's kind of a common film or literary device. Something else that bothered my friends that I didn't really mind, but I can see where they are coming from was
Spoiler:
Matt Damon's character doing the whole "crazed space man cliche"
. And that was actually another problem with the movie: there were too many familiar faces. I mean shit, put a couple relatively unknown people in there. I like
Spoiler:
Matt Damon
actually, but seeing him was just irritating and took me out of that whole sequence, quite frankly.
Originally posted by Quincy
The film also contains quite possibly the worst monologue this year, in which Anne Hathaway waxes philosophic about love.
Yeah, that was poorly done.. an interesting idea, but bad direction.
My opinion: Nolan shouldn't do this kind of visual spectacle science fiction because his style is so conceptual and bland visually. I got really bored with cutting back and forth to the mundane corn field (almost thought I was watching Signs or Field of Dreams), and I was extremely disappointed that most of the space and alternate planet stuff wasn't properly filmed. The great excitement came from docking f#cking space ships like this was Gravity all over again. Oh, that and
Spoiler:
huge f#cking waves that they stupidly mistook for mountains.
That was some really stupid shit.