Revees Superman vs

Started by Star4282 pages
Star428 Restricted
Originally posted by Silent Master
Assumptions aren't usable as feats.

In that case, Xavier has never mind-controlled a Kryptonian before. You're "assuming" that he can do it easily. I don't see how that's any different from assuming Superman can resist it since it was shown he does have considerable power over the mind.

Silent Master Senior Member

No, that is you assuming that being an alien somehow makes him immune to tp.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, that is you assuming that being an alien somehow makes him immune to tp.

According to your line of thinking it is not an assumption it is an fact since Xavier has never done so.

Silent Master Senior Member

Prof X has controlled plenty of minds, the assumption being made is that Supes being an alien makes him immune to tp.

Star428 Restricted

Reeve Superman's mind is radically different and obviously more powerful than any human's. It's not like it's just a little bit different than any mind that Xavier has controlled before. It's immensely different. Sorry, but you're "assuming" just as much as I or the other poster is when you automatically assume that Mr. X can take over a krptonian's mind that easily.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
Prof X has controlled plenty of minds, the assumption being made is that Supes being an alien makes him immune to tp.

You can't have it both ways. I provided a feat that allowed for a reasonable assumption which you did not want to accept. However, you want everyone to accept a assumption that you feel is reasonable based upon a feat perform by Xavier.

That is bias and double standard. If you are only going by feats performed in the movies with no assumptions then it is not an assumption that Superman is immune since he has never been telepathically controlled neither has Xavier telepathically controlled an alien.

Time Immemorial Restricted
Originally posted by Silent Master
No, that is you assuming that being an alien somehow makes him immune to tp.

Proof of burden is on you to prove he can control power aliens. Anyone who showed strong will resisted him.

#Facts

K-Dog Senior Member

My assumption would be that Superman's mind is proportionately as strong as his body compared to a human. I don't see Xavier even comng close.

Hancock, Silver Surfer, Thor.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by K-Dog
My assumption would be that Superman's mind is proportionately as strong as his body compared to a human. I don't see Xavier even comng close.

Hancock, Silver Surfer, Thor.


Excellent line up. This is one line up without Dr. Manhattan that I can actually see Reeve's superman losing here. I am not sure if there is any possibility for him winning here at all.

LOL No Restricted

Originally posted by Kotor3
Excellent line up. This is one line up without Dr. Manhattan that I can actually see Reeve's superman losing here. I am not sure if there is any possibility for him winning here at all.
honestly Thor and Hancock would just get in surfers wsy.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by LOL No
honestly Thor and Hancock would just get in surfers wsy.

I personally don't see surfer winning one on one. They would definitely turn the tide in their favor.