OT Vader, RotS Dooku and SoD Maul versus TOR

The Emperor gathers his apprentices and gives them a task of great importance.
They are to travel back in time and wipe out powerful force-users from the TOR era.
First they battle the Jedi, and if they clear, with health restored they battle the Sith.
Can they complete the mission?

Neutral setting. No nexus/amp.

Jedi:
Revan, HoT, Barsen’thor

Sith:
Vitiate, Scourge, Malgus

Mauls the weak link.

Falls at 1.

They fall at 1.

Originally posted by Nalaniel
They fall at 1.

I'm not sure if Barsen'thor can take Maul down. Maul is also a force-beast and should be a better duelist.

Revan vs Vader and HoT vs Dooku would be close, but I give the overall edge to Sidious's apprentices.

Good thread! Team Jedi is an interesting match for these three.

Originally posted by Stigma
I'm not sure if Barsen'thor can take Maul down. Maul is also a force-beast and should be a better duelist.

Revan vs Vader and HoT vs Dooku would be close, but I give the overall edge to Sidious's apprentices.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Maul's more of a TK beast than a Force beast, and the Barsen'thor should have no problem dealing with his TK.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Doubtful. While Vader might be able to handle Revan 1 on 1, the HoT can definitely deal with Dooku before Vader could finish Revan.

Originally posted by Stigma
That’s nice… but Maul will also have no problem dealing with Barsen’thor’s TK.
They are comparable force-wise, whereas Maul is a better duelist.

He will pose a big problem to Barsen’thor in sabers and eventually overcome him in all-out.

The only thing that is doubtful is your assertion that HoT is above Dooku.

Similarly to Barsen’thor/Maul situation I see them as relatively equal in the force department,

while Dooku holds an advantage as a duelist.

It will be close, but ultimately the good Count prevails.

Maul really isn't comparable to 'Thor, Force-wise.

Originally posted by Nalaniel
They fall at 1.

They stomp 1.

Barsen is featless as a duelist, and a one off TK showing doesn't prove he/she can hang with high tier duelists like Vader or Tyranus. Revan gets telekinetically destroyed by Vader, and Hero isn't carrying his team to victory.

They stomp 2 as well.

Clear

The Barsen'thor has more than a one-off TK showing.

They will beat Jedi team due to their superior skills with sabers. Barsen’thor is far from being at Sidious' and Yoda'ss level in TK, so I doubt that he will be able to beat anyone of PT team.

Sith team will be much harder to beat because of Vitiate. Anyway, I think that either Dooku or Vader will be able to hold-off Vitiate, while the other one will destroy Malgus. In the same time, Maul will be able to kill Scourge.

Vader alone should be sufficient for an unamped/unboosted Vitiate. But I agree they'll have more difficulty with the Sith, Malgus should be able to hold of either. Scourge is fodder to any of them though

The Barsen'thor beating an ancient Sith Lord who was drawing on the power of hundreds of Jedi Masters, while wounded and after fighting through his capital ship is a superior feat to anything Maul has done. She'd kick his ass.

It also goes without saying that the TOR Sith team win.

Mace's TK showings in CW cartoon are also superior to Sidious' from the movies. Nihilus' drain showings are also superior to anything that other Sith Lords have ever shown. Sometimes, that kind of "feats" means nothing.

Originally posted by Nephthys
The Barsen'thor beating an ancient Sith Lord who was drawing on the power of hundreds of Jedi Masters, while wounded and after fighting through his capital ship is a superior feat to anything Maul has done. She'd kick his ass.

It also goes without saying that the TOR Sith team win.

Barsen has defeated no one with feats, and lacks any saber skills to suggest he is even better than Obi Wan ROTS. Unless you have anything more substantial than beating some random fodder Sith, Barsen has got nothing on either of the three as duelists.

Maul can easily outduel Barsen, he doesn't need the force to kick Barsen's ass.

Originally posted by Zett
Mace's TK showings in CW cartoon are also superior to Sidious' from the movies. Nihilus' drain showings are also superior to anything that other Sith Lords have ever shown. Sometimes, that kind of "feats" means nothing.

Mace's TK feats were done in a cartoon that was heavily stylised and exaggerated. Every character was performing feats superior to those of Sidious. And Nihilus' drain showing straight up is superior to anything that any other Sith Lord has shown. 😐

You can't just ignore the feat for no reason, bro.

Originally posted by carthage
Barsen has defeated no one with feats, and lacks any saber skills to suggest he is even better than Obi Wan ROTS. Unless you have anything more substantial than beating some random fodder Sith, Barsen has got nothing on either of the three as duelists.

Maul can easily outduel Barsen, he doesn't need the force to kick Barsen's ass.

Gee, it's almost as if the Barsen'thor is a combatant who focuses on fighting with the Force or something, durrr!

She will toss him around before it becomes a lightsaber duel. And she has dodged lightning and blitzed large Rakatan war droids.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Mace's TK feats were done in a cartoon that was heavily stylised and exaggerated. Every character was performing feats superior to those of Sidious. And Nihilus' drain showing straight up is superior to anything that any other Sith Lord has shown. 😐

You can't just ignore the feat for no reason, bro.

Was OCW retconned?

Maybe.