Darth Malak vs Barsenthor

Started by carthage4 pages
carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Darth Malak vs Barsenthor

Round 1: Unamped Malak

Round 2: SF amp

All out

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Darth Malak on the Star Forge can pull through probably. (inb4 Neph says Darth Malak sucks, yet every other source says otherwise.)

The Merchant Senior Member

Barsen'thor.

Nalaniel Senior Member

Not sure about round 2, but Barsen'thor definitely takes round 1.

Sinious Yo Da Best
Originally posted by Nalaniel
Not sure about round 2, but Barsen'thor definitely takes round 1.

👆

Exactly my thoughts.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

The Barsen'thor wins both rounds. Malak doesn't suck, no. But 'Thor is in the top 5 most powerful Jedi to ever live in my estimation, with some of the best TK and combat feats of anyone. She's simply more powerful, more skilled and a better fighter than Malak is. Even with the SF amp he can't take her. This is the guy who lost to a tired Kotor Revan multiple times. I think the Barsen'thor can take him once.

Nalaniel Senior Member

Originally posted by Sinious
👆

Exactly my thoughts.

I'm in your head. 😂

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Originally posted by Nephthys
This is the guy who lost to a tired Kotor Revan multiple times. I think the Barsen'thor can take him once.

You threw in "Kotor" as if that makes it lesser, which I don't understand. Drew even stated that, "on some days, the younger, pre-rebirth Revan might be stronger (then Revan from TOR). Revan might have been tired, yes, but most fights in Star Wars aren't perfectly balanced situations. In response to "multiple times", for a full Lightside path, Revan could have used the Force to free the Jedi captives (similar to a Wall of Light technique), something that the KotORPG states injured Darth Malak when he went and drained it (makes a lot of sense really, a Sith Lord draining an area encased in the lightside will obviously damage a darksider). Everything was relative.
Barsen'thor might win more times then Darth Malak, given that she was able to overcome the First Son, but like against Revan, it will be "brutal" for both of them. 🙂

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

I see no reason why Barsen takes sabers in any round

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

You never played KotOR or TOR.
I see no reason why you even entered this topic.

FreshestSlice Eternal Commander

If Malak can heal, he might take round 2, and I'm guessing he can.

Fated Xtasy Kami

I'm fairly certain Malak with the SF amp could take the Barsen'thor down, though with great difficulty. and the Barsen'thor would obviously take Malak unamped.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
You threw in "Kotor" as if that makes it lesser, which I don't understand. Drew even stated that, "on some days, the younger, pre-rebirth Revan might be stronger (then Revan from TOR). Revan might have been tired, yes, but most fights in Star Wars aren't perfectly balanced situations. In response to "multiple times", for a full Lightside path, Revan could have used the Force to free the Jedi captives (similar to a Wall of Light technique), something that the KotORPG states injured Darth Malak when he went and drained it (makes a lot of sense really, a Sith Lord draining an area encased in the lightside will obviously damage a darksider). Everything was relative.
Barsen'thor might win more times then Darth Malak, given that she was able to overcome the First Son, but like against Revan, it will be "brutal" for [b]both of them. 🙂 [/B]

Kotor Revan lacks Darth Revan's memories and skills. Reborn Revan eclipses his amnesiac self in force and probably lightsaber mastery. And he's likely more powerful too.

You stating Revan might not have actually beaten Malak multiple times straight up only makes Kotor Revan look worse, so nice job?

Act 1 Barsen'thor beats Malak, let alone Act 3. Beating Vivicar proves that she can take SF Malak in my eyes.

NewGuy01 perpetual
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
You never played KotOR or TOR.
I see no reason why you even entered this topic.

Because he's the one that made it?

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Because he's the one that made it?

I know; I don't want him even in his own topics.
Kotor Revan lacks Darth Revan's memories and skills. Reborn Revan eclipses his amnesiac self in force and probably lightsaber mastery. And he's likely more powerful too.

So your opinion is > the maker of Revan now? Ah, interesting.
Wrong. KotOR Revan has majority of Darth Revan's memories by the end of the game (Darth Malak, Rakata Prime, and Bastila Shan helped make such happen).
What he doesn't have are the memories of him during the Mandalorian Wars and his encounter with Lord Vitiate.
You stating Revan might not have actually beaten Malak multiple times straight up only makes Kotor Revan look worse, so nice job?

I just lol'ed. It is confirmed in canon Kotor Revan beat Malak three times. I explained this a million times to you, how have you still not processed such?
The other drain pods are up for grabs. Going strictly light-side, he frees all the remaining pods, and Darth Malak would have *probably* been injured at least once by such.
Everything I am telling you now, I already have told you before. I don't know if it's because you just ignore Darth Malak's feats or have the inability to process memories correctly, though.
Act 1 Barsen'thor beats Malak, let alone Act 3. Beating Vivicar proves that she can take SF Malak in my eyes.

Here you go.

NewGuy01 perpetual

That being said, there's a statement saying that Revan in "Revan" was far more powerful than he was as early Darth Revan.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

He wasn't Darth Revan yet when he confronted Vitiate the first time.

AncientPower The Chosen One

Malak takes sabers in both rounds and SF amp Malak takes Force.

Malak is evidently a lot more powerful than people give him credit for.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Gooooooood.

AncientPower The Chosen One

I always thought Malak was one of the most under-rated Sith, almost exactly like Dooku as a matter of fact.