Challenge my team in a fist fight

Originally posted by Delta1938
Superman isn't mentioned, but it says "Pre-CRISIS Kryptonians."

Indeed. In any case, if we were to place him, he'd undoubtedly be in Trans.

Originally posted by carver9

He's right, though. The OP says nothing about PC characters, and your hoping it won't stop people from picking those who are most likely to win.

Anyway: PC Validus and Superman. I think they'd take a majority, though it wouldn't be easy.

If we must stick to post Crisis, GA SBP and...I dunno. Finding a second is trickier then.

Originally posted by Digi
Well, ok, but the tiers thread disagrees with you, as do I. Odin would wreck PC Supes. Validus has less exploitable weaknesses, but I also think he would fall to the All-Father.

however, since carver's thread is a purely physical match/brawl, i can understand his reservation in allowing SA superman and SA validus, given that the former has casually towed dozenS of planets behind him(to name one ridiculous strength feat), and the latter proved to be vastly stronger than any SA kryptonian(s)... /shrug

Originally posted by Galan007
where strength alone is concerned, they are well above the trans-tier, imo. however, they lack versatility on average, which is why someone like odin would likely defeat them in a forum battle(despite being far less of a physical force.)

however, since carver's thread is a purely physical match/brawl, i can understand his reservation in allowing SA superman and SA validus, given that the former has casually towed dozenS of planets behind him(to name one ridiculous strength feat), and the latter proved to be vastly stronger than any SA kryptonian(s)... /shrug

Exactly. Seems like when threads are made like this, those are the first characters people resort too.

Originally posted by Galan007
where strength alone is concerned, they are well above the trans-tier, imo. however, they lack versatility on average, which is why someone like odin would likely defeat them in a forum battle(despite being far less of a physical force.)

however, since carver's thread is a purely physical match/brawl, i can understand his reservation in allowing SA superman and SA validus, given that the former has casually towed dozenS of planets behind him(to name one ridiculous strength feat), and the latter proved to be vastly stronger than any SA kryptonian(s)... /shrug

So you think SA Superman vs Odin, pure hand-to-hand, would be fairly one-sided for Superman?

What are some other Pre-CRISIS feats you can think of for Supes? Either as Superman or Superboy.

Originally posted by Delta1938
So you think SA Superman vs Odin, pure hand-to-hand, would be fairly one-sided for Superman?

Originally posted by Galan007
none.

good thread. 👆

Let the King of Canon step in.

The Plutonian and Champion with PG.

Carver, acknowledge defeat NOW!

Originally posted by Galan007
SA supes was still ridiculously weak to magic(we saw this when he fought grundy), thus odin would still win decisively h2h, thanks to his magical nature.

So let's say something protects Superman from the effects. In regards to pure strength, how do you think Odin would do against Superman?

Also, you didn't answer my other question. 😠

Originally posted by Delta1938
So let's say something protects Superman from the effects. In regards to pure strength, how do you think Odin would do against Superman?

Also, you didn't answer my other question. 😠

You didn't answer my other question.

Originally posted by carver9
You didn't answer my other question.

What was your question?

Originally posted by carver9
It would probably be the two you chose. Don't think Superman Prime had a physical showing that makes me believe he could pull a majority though. His highest showing is his fight against Monarch and Monarch was toying with him.

One Angry...I answered your question.

Originally posted by carver9
One Angry...I answered your question.

Ah okay must have missed that, sorry for that.

Originally posted by Delta1938
So let's say something protects Superman from the effects. In regards to pure strength, how do you think Odin would do against Superman?

Also, you didn't answer my other question. 😠

aside from the planetS-towing feat, he's got numerous other feats of throwing worlds all over the place.

Originally posted by Galan007
where strength alone is concerned, they are well above the trans-tier, imo. however, they lack versatility on average, which is why someone like odin would likely defeat them in a forum battle(despite being far less of a physical force.)

however, since carver's thread is a purely physical match/brawl, i can understand his reservation in allowing SA superman and SA validus, given that the former has casually towed dozenS of planets behind him(to name one ridiculous strength feat), and the latter proved to be vastly stronger than any SA kryptonian(s)... /shrug

Fair enough, and agreed. But yes, I think in a "normal" forum battle, both would lose to Odin. Which then makes the characters fair game for this thread.

srug

Originally posted by carver9
Exactly. Seems like when threads are made like this, those are the first characters people resort too.

With good reason. There are only a handful of Trans. characters who could compete in this thread, given the OP's stips. Or did you just want a thread we couldn't successfully answer? There are a few others I could throw out there, but if we're banned PC characters, SBP is the only other person I feel confident using. A few others could make it a close fight, but would ultimately lose, and the pickings are slim after SBP, SA Validus and Supes.

I would like to Supernova & Thanos go against them.

Aquaman and Namor

Fight takes place in a large body of water somewheres in Rural Maine..

I win!!

Eat your hotdog salad now!!